There’s pace and then there’s just a general lack of fitness/sharpness our players never had.
Davies and Sigurdsson can be as fit or sharp as they like but they’ll never be able to compete with top 6 midfields because all of them have the pace and power to run all over them. When you add slow players like Bernard, Tosun, Keane, Kenny around them then it adds to a team that cannot sd anything but sit deep. It can’t hit on the counter, it can’t press effectively, it can’t break teams down on the rare occasion it’s in possession.
The only player without pace in our team good enough to indulge is James. Anyone else though can’t be carried. We can’t afford to be playing any of the names above on a regular basis and we definitely can’t play multiple combinations of them together.
If you go through the lineups of Liverpool, Chelsea, Spurs, United, City. They don’t carry slow players. They pay the money to get pace and power all over the pitch, especially Liverpool. Wijnaldum. Henderson, Keita, Fabinho, Thiago. They all are strong and rapid. So are the full backs, and the front three, and the centrebacks. When one is injured a player of a very similar profile takes their place. When we take Doucoure off we bring on Sigurdsson or Davies and completely lose control of the midfield, the drop is huge. If we lose Richarlison it’s Bernard coming on. If DCL goes its Tosun. In each scenario we’re losing pace and power and replacing them with slow weak players. We can’t survive in the modern prem with those types of players anymore.
Fortunately recent recruitment of Doucoure Nkonkou Godfrey
Branthwaite all seem to have the necessary pace and physical profile to play at the top level.