Current Affairs Israel is an apartheid state

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think this is the issue tbh. Palestinians and Israelis could live together fine. Unfortunately Palestine has been effectively taken over by Hamas, a terrorist group. It is they who fire the rockets and invade, kill and abduct Israelis not the Palestinians. The problem is how to get rid of Hamas, who have brought absolutely no benefit to the Gaza Strip, but who continually poke Israelis in the eye. Get rid of Hamas and the two communities will get along fine. Hamas doesn’t give a crap about the Gaza Strip nor the two million people who may suffer the consequences of their abhorrent actions. Get rid of Hamas and life will be better for everyone……..
Israelis have been kidnapping and murdering Palestinians for decades ffs

It makes me mad the right wing lies
 
Israelis have been kidnapping and murdering Palestinians for decades ffs

It makes me mad the right wing lies
Also stealing Land.

Maps_1897-Present.jpg
 
I think this is the issue tbh. Palestinians and Israelis could live together fine. Unfortunately Palestine has been effectively taken over by Hamas, a terrorist group. It is they who fire the rockets and invade, kill and abduct Israelis not the Palestinians. The problem is how to get rid of Hamas, who have brought absolutely no benefit to the Gaza Strip, but who continually poke Israelis in the eye. Get rid of Hamas and the two communities will get along fine. Hamas doesn’t give a crap about the Gaza Strip nor the two million people who may suffer the consequences of their abhorrent actions. Get rid of Hamas and life will be better for everyone……..

pete - removing Hamas will not solve this problem by itself; the reason Hamas exists (ie: the occupation) has to be dealt with too
 
It is terrifying that the media coverage on this is completely one sided as usual and the reality of things are blurred so much that it blinds people to the truth. Israel will kill 10 times as many innocent Palestinians in the days to come but the main headline is what hamas did. Much like last year where after the conflict, Palestine got red cross packages at the cease fire and Israel got all their rockets restocked.

It scares me as well that in times of this conflict the voice of Palestine is never heard, the story is for Vs against Jews which is not the story at all and hasn't been for 70 years but the media and famous Jewish celebrities are actively pushing this as an act against Jewish people.

One side fight for their lives and the other fight to take their land. They are not the same.
 
I think this is the issue tbh. Palestinians and Israelis could live together fine. Unfortunately Palestine has been effectively taken over by Hamas, a terrorist group. It is they who fire the rockets and invade, kill and abduct Israelis not the Palestinians. The problem is how to get rid of Hamas, who have brought absolutely no benefit to the Gaza Strip, but who continually poke Israelis in the eye. Get rid of Hamas and the two communities will get along fine. Hamas doesn’t give a crap about the Gaza Strip nor the two million people who may suffer the consequences of their abhorrent actions. Get rid of Hamas and life will be better for everyone……..
Do you genuinely believe this Pete..?
 
I think this is the issue tbh. Palestinians and Israelis could live together fine. Unfortunately Palestine has been effectively taken over by Hamas, a terrorist group. It is they who fire the rockets and invade, kill and abduct Israelis not the Palestinians. The problem is how to get rid of Hamas, who have brought absolutely no benefit to the Gaza Strip, but who continually poke Israelis in the eye. Get rid of Hamas and the two communities will get along fine. Hamas doesn’t give a crap about the Gaza Strip nor the two million people who may suffer the consequences of their abhorrent actions. Get rid of Hamas and life will be better for everyone……..
Pete, we have to remove the reason groups such as Hamas are able to exist. If you remove Hamas, and continue to treat Palestinians like animals, another group will take it's place. The lack of humanity shown towards innocent people for decades has created this. One person's terrorist is another person's freedom fighter.
 
If the West is doing that they are doing it in a really stupid way. For a start, if there’s a threat like that then the first objective, even before warning the public, must be to prepare for it. Our government isn’t.

As for this I don’t know what’s worse, Putin saying this is a crisis the US has allowed to fester because of its partiality and calling for a ceasefire, most of the world and every international body agreeing with him or the fact that I agree with him too.

Lindsey Graham, a US Senator, is calling for Gaza to be levelled. There are MKs going around calling for Gaza to be nuked. The leader of the opposition here is saying cutting off food and water to two million people isn’t a war crime. The PM here hasn’t even mentioned (as far as I can see) that there are hundreds of UK citizens in Gaza right now. The Israeli government has managed in five days to put us in a situation where we are about to support ethnic cleansing.

On this occasion our governments are completely and utterly wrong in the way they are handling this.
The current situation surrounding Vladimir Putin and his mafia regime, as is evident in the events in Ukraine, raises obviois concerns with respect to international law and human rights. This is nothing new with Putin though as his war criminality starts pretty much the day he came into power. Core to this is Putin’s direct influence on actors in the Middle East, specifically, the relationship between Iran and Hamas, Hezbollah etc. Putin’s regime and his network is reminiscent of fictional entities like SPECTRE, due to alleged involvement in global criminality, war crimes and mass violence. Any thought of agreeing with him or validating his voice is repulsive.

Putin's willingness to disregard the lives of his own citizens and cause harm to those he considers as brethren is evident. His strategic objectives seem to prioritise the expansion of his empire, importantly in light of these events, even at the cost of destabilising the Middle East.

Hamas will not act without the say so of their benefactors, Iran. The Iranian regime, in turn, is supported by and is supporting Putin's mafia. This raises questions about the extent to which Putin may be involved in, or at least aware of, the actions of groups like Hamas, given his strategic interests in the Middle East.

Putin's interests align with attempts to divert attention away from the West and Ukraine. One obvious tactic is by sowing division and discord in the United States. Putin’s strategy aims to paint him as a rational actor rather than a ruthless aggressor. It seems that he has successfully manipulated and influenced a significant number of people to support his agenda. That said, anyone looking at Russia’s actions in Ukraine under Putin’s orders can see that he is a ruthless war criminal. Much the same as Hamas. Netanyahu is cut of the same cloth.

The global response to these developments will rightly be unequivocally critical of the violence and aggression witnessed. There is a shared desire among the international community for a peaceful resolution to the ongoing conflicts. However, the complicating factor is the apparent psychopathic tendencies of the Iranian regime and Putin. Their interests are driven autocratic personal and political gains, and a peaceful resolution will not be in their best interests. The previous behaviours of the Israel state clearly being fundamental to this but the weekends atrocities have not been designed to help, of that I am sure.

The situation is a disgraceful failure in international leadership but underscores the need for a comprehensive understanding of the actors involved, their motivations, and their potential impact on the quest for peace and stability in the region. Also, as with Ukraine, that aggression will not be addressed head on.

But agreeing with a Putin is not helpful.
 
This gets a little messy.

Hamas and Fatah (the party of the Palestinian Authority) have been at one another's throats for decades. To oversimplify, the PLO (the organization of parties that Yasser Arafat headed as the chairman of Fatah) wasn't militant enough for Hamas. Think of the divide as the schism between the classic IRA and the provisionals. To Hamas, Arafat was a sellout. They'll accept nothing less than the whole West Bank, reparations and other demands.

It once was the case that the Palestinian territories held elections, except there was this problem in early 2006, which was that Hamas won the legislative election. Hamas refuses to recognize Israel, so international aid from the US, EU, UN and Russia was suspended. With Fatah's Mahmoud Abbas as president, they also got even less done legislatively than a divided government in the United States.

After about a year and a half of ugly back-and-forth without results, Hamas finally had enough. They more or less invaded Gaza, seized control and deported the members of Fatah in the government. The PA reciprocated in the West Bank, so when Israel says they're declaring war on Hamas, what they mean is that they're declaring war on Gaza.

There haven't been elections in the West Bank since. Mahmoud Abbas is functionally a dictator, but he's the guy the West and Russia are willing to work with, so they all recognize him as the legitimate leader. This is far from the only place in the world where the western democracies have entertained that little hypocrisy in the furtherance of policy ends.

When Hamas violently toppled Fatah there were videos and photos posted of 18 Fatah members kneeling and executed by Hamas.

Not so a deportation, unless its deportation to the afterlife.



Why post this?

Still reading this like 'oh well they weren't beheaded so that's fine'. Seems like classic diversion tactics to me.

The blood is firmly on Hamas and the 'people' (more like animals) who carried these attacks out.

So unsavoury the way these poor families murdered in this village, have been sidelined, as different sides use the beheading narrative to counter point. Kids are being killed. End of.
There's no stance, that justifies that. Israeli, Palestinian, Hamas or whatever other group, name, race, you want to assign to humans doing this to other humans. Sick.

Its incredibly sick to seemingly justify the murders by suggesting if theyre children and not babies its different.

Russian MP Sergey Markov

Friday October 13th is designated by Hamas as the day of a general pogrom against Jews. They call on Muslims around the world to attack Jews everywhere on October 13th.
And there are many Muslims in all European countries! Therefore, on October 13th there will be something like an unofficial state of emergency in all European countries.
In which cities are the largest Jewish pogroms expected? In Paris and Brussels.
Jews feel safe in Russia.

There should be severe consequences and multipe arrests tomorrow.
 
Calling out and providing evidence of the antisemitic / anti Israel agenda in the Labour Party and its supporters is not adult discussion? Let me guess you don’t like the truth?

All you have to do is look at the way you lot are acting on here, right down to the name of the thread.

As a centrist I hate racists of the far left and far right. It truly is amazing watching you absolute fools talk utter garbage.


Hey mate, check out the Tattoo thread, lots of wokes to educate in here!: https://www.grandoldteam.com/forum/threads/tattoos.118371/page-5

I don't know what their problem is but I'm certain it has something to do with Hunter Biden's laptop. Best of luck mate, thanks for all your help in this thread!
 
Its disgusting the amount of support Israel is getting in the media.

I get it, Terrorists bad, but Israel is a terrorist state and both should be treated with the same contempt.

You'd be ok with your friends, family and neighbours suffering an attack from a terror group like the one weve just seen?

Then receiving no support?

The double standard with Israel and Palestine leaves us in moral darkness​

Moustafa Bayoumi
Moustafa Bayoumi


Biden and Zelenskiy support a war they say was ‘unprovoked’ but a defenseless population will pay for media misinformation
Wed 11 Oct 2023 11.00 BST

I always dread watching US news coverage of wars, and now is no exception. After Hamas’s deadly attacks in Israel and Israel’s hellish bombardment of Gaza, I checked in on MSNBC. Before long, I heard one of their reporters talk about “the violent history between these two nations” – as if Palestine were a country – and had to turn off the TV to get a break. Palestine is not a country. That’s the whole point. Palestinians in Gaza, the West Bank, and Israel all live under various regimes of organized discrimination and oppression, much of which makes life nearly unlivable, and if the US media can’t even frame the issue correctly, what use is there in even covering it?
It’s not just laziness either. The reflexive identification with Israel, by both US media professionals and politicians, always obscures the fuller picture of what’s happening between Israel and the Palestinians. On 7 October, the National Security Council spokesperson Adrienne Watson stated that the US “unequivocally condemns the unprovoked attacks by Hamas terrorists against Israeli civilians”. Every one of us must stand up and denounce the killing of every civilian, Israeli or Palestinian or otherwise. But Watson’s use of the word “unprovoked” is doing a lot of work here.


What exactly counts as a provocation? Not, apparently, the large number of settlers, more than 800 by one media account, who stormed al-Aqsa mosque on 5 October. Not the 248 Palestinians killed by Israeli forces or settlers between 1 January and 4 October of this year. Not the denial of Palestinian human rights and national aspirations for decades. One can, in fact must, see such actions as provocations without endorsing further murderous violence against civilians. But if you watched only US news, you would be likely to presume that Palestinians always act while Israel only reacts. You might even think that Palestinians are the ones colonizing the land of Israel, no less. And you probably believe that Israel, which holds ultimate control over the lives of 5 million Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza and yet denies them the right to vote in Israeli elections, is a democracy.
To be considered a political being you must at the very least be considered a human being. Who gets to count as human? “I have ordered a complete siege on the Gaza Strip. There will be no electricity, no food, no fuel, everything is closed. We are fighting human animals and we are acting accordingly,” Israel’s defense minister Yoav Gallant said. Human animals? How can such language and an announced policy of collective punishment against all the residents of Gaza be seen by Israel’s supporters in the United States or elsewhere as defensible? Let’s be clear: Gallant’s language is not the rhetoric of deterrence. It’s the language of genocide.
There’s the nagging hypocrisy of the war in Ukraine. So many around the world support Ukraine’s resistance to foreign occupation (as they should) but blithely deny Palestinians any way to resist their occupation. Even non-violent methods of resistance like the boycott, divestment and sanctions campaign is vilified and even criminalized. Why the double standard? Unsurprisingly, such stances go all the way to the top. The Ukraine president Volodymyr Zelenskiy has twice voiced unilateral support for Israel in recent days, saying that “Israel’s right to self-defense is unquestionable”. Would he say the same for Russia on his territory? Of course not. Zelenskiy ought to see how his invaded and occupied land is more akin to the situation of the Palestinians than the Israelis. The obfuscations are everywhere.
So are the double standards. We will certainly hear a great deal in the United States about the Israeli Americans killed or abducted by Hamas, as we should, but will those same voices rise to the same volume for Palestinian Americans threatened and killed in Gaza? Did they also demand answers when the Israeli military shot and killed the Palestinian American journalist Shireen Abu Akleh in May 2022?
The double standard may be expected considering how the plight of the Palestinians has been discussed in the past, but that doesn’t eliminate its moral darkness. It’s also particularly dangerous and tone-deaf at this moment, when we’re on the cusp of a government – Israel – using unprecedented violence on a largely defenseless and penned-in population, in part to cover for its own fatal mistakes and embarrassment.
One fundamental way this double standard operates is through a false equivalence, a two-sides-ism that hides the massive asymmetry of power between the state of Israel and the scattered population groupings that make up the Palestinian people. They’re not equal. One dominates while the other is dominated. One colonizes. The other is colonized.
At least since the Oslo accords of 1993, we’ve been sold various promises that the way out of this injustice was negotiated settlements; after generations of enormous human sacrifice, Palestinians would finally achieve their national aspirations. It was already clear to many of us that this had long ago become a necessary illusion maintained by the powerful. Today, a negotiated peace seems farther away than ever.
This both saddens and frightens me. We are very likely entering another long and painful era where armed struggle and violent domination become increasingly and mutually dependent on each other for survival. Yet neither can win. The Palestinians will remain. They cannot be eliminated. Israel too will continue to exist. The future is full of unnecessary and horrific bloodshed all around. Desperate western attachment to morally bankrupt double standards bears a large portion of the blame.
  • Moustafa Bayoumi is the author of the award-winning books How Does It Feel to Be a Problem?: Being Young and Arab in America and This Muslim American Life: Dispatches from the War on Terror. He is a professor of English at Brooklyn College, City University of New York. He is a contributing opinion writer at the Guardian US

That man is absolutely disgusting, didnt get past the first couple of paragraphs.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top