Succession Planning - Managerial Wishlist

Rob17896 said:
I think he would be an upgrade. Win 3-0 on Monday and my fickle opinion may change until the next defeat.
Click to expand...
Id sooner keep Moyes (I'm no Myes fan btw) than go for Howe, he is utterly woeful. Teams can't defend, suffer high injuries because he runs players into the ground like Dyche did. Wants way more control over stuff than the likes of Moyes do, you think Moyes can be a troublemaker when he wants, well Howe can be a seriously awkward customer at times. The main reason for a NO from me though, Howe wants his keeper to be able to play out from the back and be decent with their feet (that's not Pickford whatever anyone on here tries to claim) but if you look at his record with goalkeepers over the years its terrible, Pope, Ramsdale, Begovic its people like that, I wouldn't trust him in a million years to pick a keeper. Don't even get me started on the helmet he has next too him.
 
Rob17896 said:
I think he would be an upgrade. Win 3-0 on Monday and my fickle opinion may change until the next defeat.
Click to expand...
Why do you think he's an upgrade?Spent huge amounts and Newcastle are below us in the table. Newcastle fans basically say Isak last season papered over the cracks of his poor tactics. His teams never look the most organised either. I just don't see why anyone thinks he'd be an upgrade as to me he's a similar level to Moyes who plays a slightly better brand of football
 
♧
Simon Buttle said:
Id sooner keep Moyes (I'm no Myes fan btw) than go for Howe, he is utterly woeful. Teams can't defend, suffer high injuries because he runs players into the ground like Dyche did. Wants way more control over stuff than the likes of Moyes do, you think Moyes can be a troublemaker when he wants, well Howe can be a seriously awkward customer at times. The main reason for a NO from me though, Howe wants his keeper to be able to play out from the back and be decent with their feet (that's not Pickford whatever anyone on here tries to claim) but if you look at his record with goalkeepers over the years its terrible, Pope, Ramsdale, Begovic its people like that, I wouldn't trust him in a million years to pick a keeper. Don't even get me started on the helmet he has next too him.
Click to expand...
Would prefer another go with Silva
 
Marcus Kendall said:
Why do you think he's an upgrade?Spent huge amounts and Newcastle are below us in the table. Newcastle fans basically say Isak last season papered over the cracks of his poor tactics. His teams never look the most organised either. I just don't see why anyone thinks he'd be an upgrade as to me he's a similar level to Moyes who plays a slightly better brand of football
Click to expand...
I can see there is an argument but Moyes plays a better brand than Dyche and maybe one or two others. Great when we were skint but cant visualise much beyond where we are.
 
Rob17896 said:
I can see there is an argument but Moyes plays a better brand than Dyche and maybe one or two others. Great when we were skint but cant visualise much beyond where we are.
Click to expand...
I'm not against changing manager I just struggle to see why you're limiting your vision to someone because they've done okay in the Premier League. Howe isn't terrible by any means but I don't think he's the type who can raise a club to the higher heights of the Premier League consistently unless he has a massive budget which he won't have here. Also a big factor is his teams tend to be injury prone which we can't afford with our lack of depth generally. If we have to pick from the Premier League then Iraola is the obvious candidate. But there are managers in other leagues doing great work so why not give one of them a chance? Or do we need a Premier League experienced manager?
 
Marcus Kendall said:
I'm not against changing manager I just struggle to see why you're limiting your vision to someone because they've done okay in the Premier League. Howe isn't terrible by any means but I don't think he's the type who can raise a club to the higher heights of the Premier League consistently unless he has a massive budget which he won't have here. Also a big factor is his teams tend to be injury prone which we can't afford with our lack of depth generally. If we have to pick from the Premier League then Iraola is the obvious candidate. But there are managers in other leagues doing great work so why not give one of them a chance? Or do we need a Premier League experienced manager?
Click to expand...
I mentioned in another that there may be but I don't look at much beyond our league, in fact much beyond our team. Other peoples job.
 
Rob17896 said:
I mentioned in another that there may be but I don't look at much beyond our league, in fact much beyond our team. Other peoples job.
Click to expand...
It is other people's jobs. With the Friedkins owning a club in Italy and to a lesser degree France I'm fairly confident they have good knowledge of the European manager market and who's showing promise etc. So I'd be surprised if Howe was even on their radar not to mention there's no guarantee Newcastle will sack him either
 
smileychap said:
CL qualification, silverware, made a packet on Isak. And he's an everton fan, right?

On the odd game I watch them they seem to have a go, too.

What drawbacks do you see for Howe...
Click to expand...
Injury prone teams
Inconsistent form and major slumps
Look unorganised at the back
Newcastle fans say Isak papered over the cracks last season as the football wasn't great
Spent huge and are below us in the table
Winning cups is nice but with the budget he's had they should be looking to be a consistent top 4 squad especially as Man Utd, Spurs and Chelsea have been average the last couple of seasons.
Look at Emery at Villa with less resources that's what a manager of Newcastle should be doing

But he's a blue right. And his teams have a go against the bigger sides. Shame they don't against the lesser sides and drop points against them

Do you honestly think he'd improve us?
 
As a club when we do go for another manager we need to think outside the box and go for someone like Bournemouth or Brentford have done.

Brentford for example when they came to Hill Dickinson totally played us off the park. tactics with lesser players 👌
 

Similar Threads

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

→ Log in 🔑 Register
🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top