Martinez Sentiment Poll: In or Out

[daz4matty]

McCarthy and Barry.

McCarthy is a very good player. I just don't think he's 16m better than Besic or even 13m better than Cleverly.

Cleverley is truly cack for a start.
We should build our midfield round jimmy mac but hopefully it won't be martinez rebuilding

 

[MikeH72]

Pipe down eh.

Martinez is safe as houses.

There's no realistic candidate to replace him and he's on a five year contract.

Safety > end of season > Martinez summer transfers > 2015/16 season.

That's the sequence.

Honestly, you're going to do yourselves a mischief. I fear for the sanity of some. It's a poor football season for Everton FC. Hard lines that, but there we have it. We cant have good ones every year. It isn't guaranteed. But no one was killed. We live to fight another day. Let's try to move on with a bit of dignity.

Thoughts?

Do you acknowledge that Martinez has been 80% of the reason we've had such a poor season?

 

[MikeH72]

Alvin Martin was spot on: you dont get rid of a talented manager v=because you go through a poor season.

Outsiders see it easy enough.

Good job we don't have one of those to get rid of then isn't it?

 

[flibbyflob]

Do you acknowledge that Martinez has been 80% of the reason we've had such a poor season?

Only 80%?

His team with his signings and tactics.

 

[blackmore1977]

The biggest tragedy of this season is our best (even the underperforming ones) players will not be here next season. There's no way the core of: Stones, Coleman, Garbutt, Baines, McCarthy, Besic, Barkley, Mirallas, Lukaku, will be intact next season. Can easily see two or three of those being picked off in the summer. I can just about buy the idea of giving Martinez the benefit of the doubt, a summer to take a long hard look at himself (and his tactics), and the first 10+ games of next season, however, i'm not sure i trust him to find adequate replacements. In the day's of Europe being upmost to players, money and agents in their ears, i can see our club dropping away very quickly, and a further talent drain summer 2016 if we are not back up around the top 7 next season. This season i can just about rationalise, but next season is probably the biggest in our history and Roberto's approach this season is not filling me with confidence. I think the above scenario is what is underpinning a lot of the knee jerk reactions, fear of the future.

 

[Khalekan]

Talksport is worth a listen.

talkSPORT is never worth a listen, Ian.

Especially when Durham is on....

 

[Tubey]

The biggest tragedy of this season is our best (even the underperforming ones) players will not be here next season. There's no way the core of: Stones, Coleman, Garbutt, Baines, McCarthy, Besic, Barkley, Mirallas, Lukaku, will be intact next season. Can easily see two or three of those being picked off in the summer. I can just about buy the idea of giving Martinez the benefit of the doubt, a summer to take a long hard look at himself (and his tactics), and the first 10+ games of next season, however, i'm not sure i trust him to find adequate replacements. In the day's of Europe being upmost to players, money and agents in their ears, i can see our club dropping away very quickly, and a further talent drain summer 2016 if we are not back up around the top 7 next season. This season i can just about rationalise, but next season is probably the biggest in our history and Roberto's approach this season is not filling me with confidence. I think the above scenario is what is underpinning a lot of the knee jerk reactions, fear of the future.

He's not going to do that. He'll never do that. He's said so himself.

 

[USABlue]

The biggest tragedy of this season is our best (even the underperforming ones) players will not be here next season. There's no way the core of: Stones, Coleman, Garbutt, Baines, McCarthy, Besic, Barkley, Mirallas, Lukaku, will be intact next season. Can easily see two or three of those being picked off in the summer. I can just about buy the idea of giving Martinez the benefit of the doubt, a summer to take a long hard look at himself (and his tactics), and the first 10+ games of next season, however, i'm not sure i trust him to find adequate replacements. In the day's of Europe being upmost to players, money and agents in their ears, i can see our club dropping away very quickly, and a further talent drain summer 2016 if we are not back up around the top 7 next season. This season i can just about rationalise, but next season is probably the biggest in our history and Roberto's approach this season is not filling me with confidence. I think the above scenario is what is underpinning a lot of the knee jerk reactions, fear of the future.

Coleman and Barkley won't go because they've had rough seasons and no one's going to pay as much as we'd want for them. Can only see garbutt, kev, and rom going if there's enough interest and they want to leave

 

[IllinoisBlue]

I can't get my head around the fact that Martinez was given probably a larger transfer kitty than Moyes ever had and we went BACKWARDS!!!!!!!!

 

[royalblue66]

His interviews after the game yestersay and today are insults to every proper Evertonian.

Im gonna take a time off from Everton till this clown is sacked

Over and out

I don't listen to his interviews anymore,I find him embarrassing.

 

[Christiffa25]

Cleverley is truly cack for a start.
We should build our midfield round jimmy mac but hopefully it won't be martinez rebuilding

Yep new manager with new tactics!

I'd play McCarthy has the 1 holding midfielder. A little like chelsea do with matic and arse do with ???? Can't remember his name haha the young lad (coq somet)

 

[sageyefc]

I can't get my head around the fact that Martinez was given probably a larger transfer kitty than Moyes ever had and we went BACKWARDS!!!!!!!!

So...

In comparison with the rest of the league we still were low spenders

 

[marty mcfly]

Cleverley is truly cack for a start.
We should build our midfield round jimmy mac but hopefully it won't be martinez rebuilding

He's doing well under Sherwood. He was just a name I picked because we had been linked with him

Alex Song is available for how much?

If he joined he would be our best defensive midfielder and would probably cost no more than a few million.

I like McCarthy so I'm not going to continue this but playing him alongside Barry has had it's day.

I want to see Barkley play there for the remainder of the season alongside either McCarthy or Besic. Lennon on the right and Atsu on the left and Naismith until we can find a replacement playing as a No10 until the end of the season.

 

[daz4matty]

Coleman and Barkley won't go because they've had rough seasons and no one's going to pay as much as we'd want for them. Can only see garbutt, kev, and rom going if there's enough interest and they want to leave

The people in football know the players are quality though.
I bet louis van fats will be in for coleman he is class.
I don't know about ross somebody could take a chance because again he is quality

 

[blackmore1977]

He's not going to do that. He'll never do that. He's said so himself.

well he better go the job centre now hadn't he? ha ha