Top Ten Toffee Stinkers

[Neiler]

He was getting chants after two games for us. He did well but only played about 20 games for us and was then out injured for about 3 years.

Not for me mate, but then I saw a lot of the player he was.

 

[The Binman]

Billic

 

[PhilRegan]

Of those, Silva, Castillo, Westerveld & Baardsen were loans, the last two emergency goalkeepers who only played because of injuries to regular keepers. Bosnar didn't play a single minute of football for the first team. Rodrigo cost peanuts iirc, and suffered a pretty bad injury soon after joining us. I'll give you VDM and Bakayoko, though even those two had their moments.

Personally think they were all atrocious signings myself

 

[monty]

Well this thread proves one thing, we are tops when it comes to dross, sadly it's us, the fans, who had to watch each and every one of them. AARRRGGGGHHHHHH

 

[daza_1973]

Bilic, williamson, mitch ward, tony thomas, john o kane, madar, spencer, claus thomsen, brett angell, steve simonsen, richard wright....

Frightening

Although Gareth Farrellys worldie and Chelsea's job on Bolton are remembered more - Madar's small haul of goals massively helped keep us up in 1998.

 

[maccavennie]

Although Gareth Farrellys worldie and Chelsea's job on Bolton are remembered more - Madar's small haul of goals massively helped keep us up in 1998.

I only put Madar in for a sitter he missed at Anfield. Like you said, he scored a few good goals.

Farrelly stays out of my list due to his wonder strike which I think was the only thing he done but if your gonna do one thing, score a goal to keep us up!

 

[firefighterblue]

Joe Harper. Record goalscorer for Aberdeen. Remember his first game for us. Looked totally unfit, ok fat then, touch of an elephant. Never lasted long
Had a ook at his stats for us says 43 appearances and 12 goals. Maybe I'm wrong then

 

[Jamestrueblue]

That Brazilian lad jo what a shower of ####

 

[steven]

Cuco Martina is the worst player to ever kick a ball for us, convince me otherwise.

I raise oumar niasse

 

[BernieH]

Garry Rowett

 

[Noble Savage]

Garry Rowett

Oooo good shout . Everyone had high hopes for him too. Had a half decent career after he left us .

 

[BernieH]

Oooo good shout . Everyone had high hopes for him too. Had a half decent career after he left us .

He's a lower league manager now isn't he

 

[Noble Savage]

He's a lower league manager now isn't he

I think he is . He has bounced around the championship and tiers 3 and 4 .

 

[canuckblue]

It would be easier to list the top 10 non-stinkers.

 

[monty]

Ernie Hunt, the slowest milkman in the west.