Top Ten Toffee Stinkers

[daza_1973]

Madar had a little purple patch then cried when hurting his hand and never played for us again

A purple patch that gained us four points in a season we stayed up on goal difference.

 

[Noble Savage]

A purple patch that gained us four points in a season we stayed up on goal difference.

I loved the crazy Frenchman. He was our budget Cantona .

 

[Papa Shango]

Madar had a little purple patch then cried when hurting his hand and never played for us again

He never played for us again because Walter Smith didn't like his attitude. Shame as he was a good player, probably a player who came to us a little too early in terms of how the premier league changed over time.

 

[Papa Shango]

We must be the luckiest side ever how on earth is it possible to have signed so many crap players and not get relegated,by the way richard dunne says hi

Richard Dunne wasn't a bad player at all!

Playing him right back was probably not the best use of him though...

 

[Gaffa]

Dunne was ok. Him and Ball didnt help their own downfall and rightly so, by messing about on the coach after we lost at Bristol Rovers - which in 37 years of following the blues is still the worst night I've ever had. They were shifted out after that

 

[CairnsToffee]

Geoff Nulty
Billy Wright
Jim Pearson
Joe Harper
George Telfer
Dave Clements
David Lawson
Archie Styles
Stuart Barlow
Niasse

 

[mawders]

Has anyone mentioned Stuart Barlow yet?

 

[Lloydystark]

Has anyone mentioned Stuart Barlow yet?

Ken Barlow too

 

[Yarrgh]

I loved the crazy Frenchman. He was our budget Cantona .

The French Andy Carroll. A la poubelle.

Haircut and crockedness. Didn't punch horses or cost millions.

 

[Oxontoffee]

Richard Dunne wasn't a bad player at all!

Playing him right back was probably not the best use of him though...

Ok i thought maybe my memory was failing me,so looked up a bit of history on him 3rd most sent off player in premiership(dunc is second),record own goal scorer in premiership,it always sticks out in my memory how poor he was and saw him sent off several times for everton,just allways looked a liability to me

 

[KaiserEFC]

Simon Davies is a huge one for me. A genuinely awful player who even made a 25 yard goal look crap.

 

[the golden visionary]

Klaus Thompson

 

[Mattblue -J-]

Magaye Gueye

 

[Stan Lee Park]

My top 10 will be based on a combination of bad attitude, lack of ability, and my general hatred of them.

Schneiderlin
Van Der Meyde
Alcaraz
McGeady
Simonsen
Mangala
Kroldrup
Martina
Sandro
Nyarko

Special mention to Li Weifeng for being utterly out of his depth, but I felt sorry for him more than anything. Looked like they'd just sent him so that Li Tie wasn't lonely.

Oumar doesn't even make top 20, lack of ability aside he's never hidden when called upon.

Li Tie was rubbish as well though Almost as bad as Linderoth.

 

[PhoenixIreland]

Sorry to say, but Coleman - he's been average for the past 5 years - gives the ball away too much.