Barnfred 55
Player Valuation: £80m
I agree that their whole musical act is contrived mate. But contrived solely by themselves rather than any outside influences. When they formed the band they sat down and planned everything in detail, from the type of music they wanted to play, to their wardrobe, aesthetic, live performances and the type of audience to target. Then they started playing live shows and it seems people bought into it. But although contrived, they were in fact also being pretty true to themselves, so in that regard sort of authentic too. Live they can come across as rehearsed and I get some people won't like that, but there are many moments of spontaneity too. I disagree on the amateurish side; in fact I think they are very professional but that's absolutely fine.I can never agree with hating anyone but I can certainly see why they are not universally liked or appreciated.
You're a fan , that's great.
Me ? I think their music is contrived and amateurish. For me it's style over substance. But one person's Chablis is another person's Blue Nun.
If we all liked the same thing the world would be a pretty boring place.
As regards the two posts I made, I have absolutely no issue with people not liking the band's music. That's personal choice and we are all different as you say. I don't even have a real issue with the discourse over industry plants/ nepotism and sexism that has followed this band since their first single was released. If that's what people want to believe that's up to them. However I do question whether this is always done judiciously, i.e same rules applied to everybody. But what I was referring to, and something that does annoy me greatly, is the amount of just pure hate that is posted on line about this band. I mean stuff I couldn't post about in here without being banned. A lot of it is both personal and hurtful and I'm not aware of any other band out there right now that is going through this. I'm aware that others have in the past and they are usually female or female led, but not always. The 2 recent journals have, in my opinion, only added fuel to this hate which is why they have annoyed me so much. In one case where stuff was fabricated it was pure irresponsible journalism.
Anyway, this topic started last night as a bit of a joke and seemed to get out of hand. So it's probably best if we drop it now and don't go there again. I can do without the hassle