The 'problem' with Martinez for some Everonians was that he didn't want the team to hoof the ball downfield or into Row Z.
He wanted to play football and that got up the noses of people once we weren't;t challenging for a European place.
That ^^^ is the top and bottom of it.
No, that is not the top and bottom of it.
I can't speak for all Evertonians but my problem was that he only had one way of playing. He was stubborn and if there is one thing that that really gets under my skin in football it is the word 'philosophy'. People in football believing that football 'should' be played only one way. Barrow have recently got a new manager. In his first interview he was asked what his philosophy was and his answer was music to my ears, he said 'I don't have a philosophy, well, I suppose my philosophy is to play to win a game of football'. I can't remember it all but it went along the lines of if we have to play defensively then so be it, if we have to play it long then so be it.
In other words, Martinez's way of playing football was as dull as dishwater and was found out in 2 full seasons as easy to contend with. Now, if he had Man City money then he probably would never have been in a position where he could be criticised like he was and is. However, he did not and the players he brought in could not/did not want to play the way he wanted them to (which is also why Dyche has got so much stick). It was turgid stuff, every football fan loves a slick well oiled passing move that leads to a chance. Martinez's style and personnel was just not geared to that. He did not coach the defence to do their main job.
I want a manager who can mix it up a bit, this is where Baines and
Moyes comes into it.
Moyes is a lot more flexible, and considers the opposition a lot more. Now, you still have to have the main focus on your own team but if a manager or coach sees that a team has a high press then passing it around the back will not work, you have to push them back with long balls over the top of them. If Baines has a voice in this set up then maybe he learned off Martinez but not in the way you would want. His comments were absolutely spot on, no cohesion, no chemistry, just one way of playing that the players were not really comfortable with.
Baines has a group of people who hopefully do not have a 'philosophy'. We know that Moyes doesn't really have one and you would assume that Irvine doesn't, given how much time he spent with Moyes Mk1. You would also assume that the other don't either. Baines is around the right people, and as said if he was coming out with astute comments like he did, when he playing, then he has the right mindset to become a successful coach/manager, the key word is adaptability. The main thing that Martinez lacked while at Everton.