2025/26 David Moyes

Only if you’re foolish enough to judge signings of players in the short term or if you expect every signing to be a success.
Who's been a success? All but one imo. I do actually like a few of them but the manager obv wasn't onboard with them signing hence the signings have been failures.
 
One of them the Mickey Mouse three handled piss pot cup that you’ve wanted us to forfeit every other season?


"No major club would value it."

Unfortunately that's not us right now, is it?

Why do you insist on shooting yourself in the foot?
 
Pretty easily. Moyes sees the players in training every day and is a very experienced coach. He is picking the players he thinks are most in form and most suit the way he wants to play which he thinks is our best chance of picking up points. Not playing players who play badly and having a settled first XI is clearly a good thing. Not sure how any one can argue to the contrary. All of the squad players have been given chances and they haven't impressed. It would be insane to just keep playing them.

They don’t have to play the whole game to contribute. Given chances & not impressed 🤔

Alcarez Palace
Aznou Sunderland
Rohl Villa
 
That's a massive load of excuses for two terrible cup efforts.
No Dave. Not excuses at all. We were poor in both those cup games and I've acknowledged that.

The point I am trying to make is that with the upturn in league performance, attention has been drawn to the cup failures. All I'm saying is that if we'd got some of the draws I mentioned of the teams that have gone deeper in the comps, then even playing poorly we could well have gone on a "cup run". Ultimately only one team will win each of those pots making the cup runs of the others meaningless in the grand scheme of things. City have won the first and we'll see what happens with the FA Cup.

I'll accept that we could've probably fielded a stronger side away at Wolves, but it still really came down to poor performance from the players. As I think is widely accepted, we were down to the bare bones when we faced Sunderland and again played poorly, but only went out on pens.

Would any of those fans that talk of cup runs and taking the cups "seriously" have been satisfied with getting to a semi final of the FA Cup having beaten the likes of Charlton, Hull, Wrexham and Port Vale (for example)? I'm not sure they would really, as only winning it has any real impact for us supporters.

I was deeply annoyed after both cup exits as I'm sure all fans were. Not sure I'm entirely convinced about the "taking it seriously" position though. Now if we'd have gone out to Mansfield and Charlton then that might be a different story.
 
No Dave. Not excuses at all. We were poor in both those cup games and I've acknowledged that.

The point I am trying to make is that with the upturn in league performance, attention has been drawn to the cup failures. All I'm saying is that if we'd got some of the draws I mentioned of the teams that have gone deeper in the comps, then even playing poorly we could well have gone on a "cup run". Ultimately only one team will win each of those pots making the cup runs of the others meaningless in the grand scheme of things. City have won the first and we'll see what happens with the FA Cup.

I'll accept that we could've probably fielded a stronger side away at Wolves, but it still really came down to poor performance from the players. As I think is widely accepted, we were down to the bare bones when we faced Sunderland and again played poorly, but only went out on pens.

Would any of those fans that talk of cup runs and taking the cups "seriously" have been satisfied with getting to a semi final of the FA Cup having beaten the likes of Charlton, Hull, Wrexham and Port Vale (for example)? I'm not sure they would really, as only winning it has any real impact for us supporters.

I was deeply annoyed after both cup exits as I'm sure all fans were. Not sure I'm entirely convinced about the "taking it seriously" position though. Now if we'd have gone out to Mansfield and Charlton then that might be a different story.

The surrender at Wolves happened and it was the aftermath of that which was the disgrace: his arrogant dismissal of us going out and defence of his team selection.

That's why he shouldn't be getting any extension unless we get Europe.

Mediocrity + arrogance = not acceptable, IMO.

We can do way better than him this summer as very decent managers become available.
 
I think last summers recruitment was slightly haphazard due to certain scouts and talent identifiers not being in position.

Some of which only took up their roles after the season started.

Am expecting to see a more coherent summer of transfer activity.

If we're going into the season still needing a CB RB and a forward someone is getting a dig.

Moyes has got to want a RB to sign one. It’s been reported he’s vetoed the ones Thelwell lined up & those recommended more recently by the committee. ☹️
 
Grealish cost around £23m fee and salary for the seasons. Hardly money well spent and we haven't missed him in the slightest. I like Grealish but not for them numbers. Players costing those numbers should be changing games for us regularly when on the pitch.

We missed him in the games we had to break down opponents defenses like Wolves, Leeds or so.
 
They don’t have to play the whole game to contribute. Given chances & not impressed 🤔

Alcarez Palace
Aznou Sunderland
Rohl Villa
They did ok in short periods but have also flopped in other games. No better than the alternatives we have and I don't see how our results would have been better if they had played more. It's a weird argument to be honest when we are in with a sniff of a Champions League place.
 
They did ok in short periods but have also flopped in other games. No better than the alternatives we have and I don't see how our results would have been better if they had played more. It's a weird argument to be honest when we are in with a sniff of a Champions League place.

It’s weird on here in general.😵‍💫
 

Similar Threads

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top