Will agree to disagree on this one.
From what I see, there's a lad who's winning most of the aerial duels that come his way, he's pretty good with his back to goal and bringing others into play and links well with others. His movement is enthusiastic, but needs refinement. He's quick enough and his control is decent.
What I'm not seeing enough of is getting into goal scoring positions, and when he has he hasn't always shown the composure you'd want.
He is pretty raw when running with the ball and I don't see that ever improving hugely.
Totally opposite to you, I can see why we bought him. To my eyes, there's a lot to work with but, as Moyes said months ago, he is a work in progress. There's a lot he needs to develop and we probably have overpaid based on how much development you'd want in some ways.
It may be a backhanded compliment, but Everton are a better team when he's on the pitch vs when Beto is.