Current Affairs The Conservative Party

Status
Not open for further replies.


He's not wrong.

He's not.

But equally, he's not mentioning all the non-trade obligations that are packaged up with access to the EU's single market.

If it was just about trade then the overwhelming majority of the country would be pro-EU membership. But it isn't just about trade. The EU demands freedom of movement as part and parcel of single market trade. It's not a functional necessity, it's just an aspect of the price member states have to agree to in order to access the single market.

But you know that. As does Sadiq Kahn.
 
He's not.

But equally, he's not mentioning all the non-trade obligations that are packaged up with access to the EU's single market.

If it was just about trade then the overwhelming majority of the country would be pro-EU membership. But it isn't just about trade. The EU demands freedom of movement as part and parcel of single market trade. It's not a functional necessity, it's just an aspect of the price member states have to agree to in order to access the single market.

But you know that. As does Sadiq Kahn.
It's an enormous benefit, not a cost. Probably a bigger benefit than the single market.
 
If he's a Tory then I am a giraffe.
I'm a Tory party member, as are dozens of my friends and family members. The chap in the video has just voiced my beliefs and values, and those of my friends / family. We're all appalled by Truss, and if you want to go diving through the vaults you'll find me being critical of Braverman back when Labour didn't even know who she was.

Genuinely find it sad that the strong left STILL just automatically label anyone centrist as a right wing zealot. It's so polarised, so black and white, so simplistic for the extreme left, because their entire identity is defined by hatred of anyone who dares think differently to them. Equally, extreme right-wingers are every bit as intolerant.

But there are dozens, if not hundreds, of sensible centrist MPs in both the Labour and Tory parties: I'd take a Labour government led by someone like Dan Jarvis tomorrow if the Burgons, Lammys, Rayners and Thornberrys were consigned to the backbenches where they belong. Equally a Tory party under Sunak or Badenoch is immediately more enlightened and centrist than Truss.

Cue all the jibes about "you can't be a centrist if you vote Tory".
 
Last edited:
It's an enormous benefit, not a cost. Probably a bigger benefit than the single market.
Conceptually, that's entirely possible. But in practical terms the voting population of the UK would overwhelmingly back a single market agreement based solely on trade, whereas there is far less support for a package deal where free trade is conditional on also accepting various other principles.

Understanding the above is not the same as agreeing that it's correct.
 
I'm a Tory party member, as are dozens of my friends and family members. The chap in the video has just voiced my beliefs and values, and those of my friends / family. We're all appalled by Truss, and if you want to go diving through the vaults you'll find me being critical of Braverman back when Labour didn't even know who she was.

Genuinely find it sad that the strong left STILL just automatically label anyone centrist as a right wing zealot. It's so polarised, so black and white, so simplistic for the extreme left, because their entire identity is defined by hatred of anyone who dares think differently to them. Equally, extreme right-wingers are every bit as intolerant.

But there are dozens, if not hundreds, or sensible centrist MPs in both the Labour and Tory parties: I'd take a Labour government led by someone like Dan Jarvis tomorrow if the Burgons, Lammys, Rayners and Thornberrys were consigned to the backbenches where they belong. Equally a Tory party under Sunak or Badenoch is immediately more enlightened and centrist than Truss.

Cue all the jibes about "you can't be a centrist if you vote Tory".
Badenoch lol.
 
Yep. I bet I could survey a few hundred thousand people who left former Warsaw pact countries to move to Germany, Sweden, Spain and France and I'd get that result too. I could also survey ten thousand residents in London and get universal support. But if I canvassed one hundred thousand people across Yorkshire (for instance) the result might well be different

The point is that member states join or don't join based on the feelings of their OWN electorate. Not on the reported beliefs of people all across the EU.
 
I imagine it would also aid growth
Indeed it might. It's fairly obvious to see how.

But the public don't want it. And the short-termism of our political system, combined with our abysmal, sensationalism-obsessed media, means that no government will risk such an unpopular move.

Truss did something horrendously unpopular last week (by way of comparison); when she saw the massive negative reaction she changed course, and the media promptly attacked her for making a "U-turn".

If you want politicians to be open about the idea of changing unpopular policies, what is the point in attacking them for changing unpopular policies? All that happens is that they become afraid of changing course.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top