The all new David Moyes poll (for Davek)

Do you want Moyes here next season or not?

  • Yes

    Votes: 299 58.7%
  • No

    Votes: 210 41.3%

  • Total voters
    509
Status
Not open for further replies.
I would have thought the Daveotees would be putting up a better argument for getting rid.
Moyslamaphobia seems to be running rampant on GOT, yet the voting suggests otherwise.
 
Emery walked into a good squad. I can still remember posts on here about how bad must gerrard be sitting in the bottom 3 with that squad. I dont think emery takes that job with any genuine relegation worries. He knew what he was walking into. Was very early in the season.
Bit like emery howe took over from bruce after 8 games. He won a trophy after 5 years and 600m spent.
Palace i cant remember them being anything other than bang in the middle of the table. Might be wrong but they always seem to be bothering neither end of the table lol.
Everton have had 5 years of either hovering around relegation or last day escapes.
I havent voted in this pole simply because i'm not sure who would be replacing him.

Everton haven't had 5 years of hovering around relegation or last day escapes prior to Moyes.

It might seem it, but it's not true.

We had 2, Palace/Bournemouth and the full season prior to him arriving we'd earned the points for 12th. The points we have now with 3 to go. Point deduction is a very valid mitigating factor.

As for comparisons to Villa as though it was just a blip - prior to Emery arriving they'd been in Championship for 3 years before promotion via play offs, then 17th, 11th and 14th. So your argument of a blip for them and it not us doesn't stand.

[edit] The argument against Emery is he's spent a fortune at Villa, but if Moyes took over I very much doubt they'd have done as well. There's a reason Emery has won 4 Europa Leagues and titles elsewhere.
 
Everton haven't had 5 years of hovering around relegation or last day escapes prior to Moyes.

It might seem it, but it's not true.

We had 2, Palace/Bournemouth and the full season prior to him arriving we'd earned the points for 12th. The points we have now with 3 to go. Point deduction is a very valid mitigating factor.

As for comparisons to Villa as though it was just a blip - prior to Emery arriving they'd been in Championship for 3 years before promotion via play offs, then 17th, 11th and 14th. So your argument of a blip for them and it not us doesn't stand.

[edit] The argument against Emery is he's spent a fortune at Villa, but if Moyes took over I very much doubt they'd have done as well. There's a reason Emery has won 4 Europa Leagues and titles elsewhere.

Moyes has a higher net spend for his second spell with us than what Emery has for Villa.
 
1778157801804.webp
 
Everton haven't had 5 years of hovering around relegation or last day escapes prior to Moyes.

It might seem it, but it's not true.

We had 2, and the full season prior to him arriving we'd earned the points for 12th. The points we have now with 3 to go.

As for comparisons to Villa as though it was just a blip - prior to Emery arriving they'd been in Championship for 3 years before promotion via play offs, then 17th, 11th and 14th. So your argument of a blip for them and it not us doesn't stand.

We've had an eye on relegation. Theres been a relegation thread on here for the past 5 years. There hasnt been one this season at all. Hovering/eye.
Villa is fair enough comment. Talking more about what emery walked into. Lots of that squad are still there that gerrard had at the bottom of the table.
 
We've had an eye on relegation. Theres been a relegation thread on here for the past 5 years. There hasnt been one this season at all. Hovering/eye.
Villa is fair enough comment. Talking more about what emery walked into. Lots of that squad are still there that gerrard had at the bottom of the table.

There was, and I took some flak for closing it.
 
The thing I always think with these 'manager stay or go' polls is that if it's split right down the middle then really the answer is to make change.

I'm obviously biased, having voted no - but don't think its helpful for the fanbase to be so divided on such a crucial issue.

With all respect, this is how we ended up with brexit. It doesn't mean one half know what they are talking about.

We have gone from consistently fighting relegation for years to having one and a half in relative peace, Everton are still mid-rebuild. We all know Moyes has a celling, but we're not there yet. He excels when things are up against it, for instance under a different manager when we lost the AFCON players, had suspensions and a load of injuries we could have well slid down into trouble again. Who knows if Ndiaye/Garner are still here next season.

We need to strengthen to a point we have a more than solid team that are challenging for the top European spots and are out spending the others year on year to grow the gap between us and the mid-table sides. Once we get to that point then a change wouldn't be so risky. Of course if there is a world class manager who wants in and has players that will fall over themselves to join, then that's a different matter.

Lots of examples this season where clubs have changed managers and have jumped out of the frying pan and into the fire. Until we have working full backs and forwards, I can't see why anyone thinks this is the time to change.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar Threads

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top