Seamus Coleman Calls Time On Everton Playing Career

Something will have to be done to correct this by the club or it'll forever be embarrassed by it.

It inspires zero loyalty among players generally to see that happen to a player they the club have often described as a legend to go out like that.

Make it good or stop that reference to him.

The club are obligated over this now.

It goes beyond Coleman. The integrity of the organisation is at stake.

A testimonial game is the only solution.
 
Something will have to be done to correct this by the club or it'll forever be embarrassed by it.

It inspires zero loyalty among players generally to see that happen to a player they the club have often described as a legend to go out like that.

Make it good or stop that reference to him.

The club are obligated over this now.

It goes beyond Coleman. The integrity of the organisation is at stake.

A testimonial game is the only solution.
I can guarantee you that the other players don't give a monkeys.

They've already moved on.
 
Wish the club would stop tweeting daily about him leaving like he's some sort of revered champion.

Villa just won Europa League and we're tweeting out him cheering on a stretcher.

The smallest of small clubs.
It's all getting weird now, we've just flushed the season down the toilet and they're tweeting him on a stretcher, which is where he's spent the majority of the last 5 years
 
Wish the club would stop tweeting daily about him leaving like he's some sort of revered champion.

Villa just won Europa League and we're tweeting out him cheering on a stretcher.

The smallest of small clubs.

They shouldn't be doing anything with his name on it until they treat him right.

They're still exploiting his legacy here even after embarrassing him with that non-send off.

How pathetic is that?
 
I don't get the big drama about his send off to be honest. We lost 3-1 at home to a newly promoted side to make it over 2 months since we last won a game, people didn't want to hang around and applaud all the players, no big deal. He's had plenty of love from the fans including during his final game, and there's probably a 75% chance he's still here next year as a coach anyway.

On the social media stuff, you just have to remember what the point of having social media channels is. They're just trying to pump out content and get engagement - they're not deliberately celebrating mediocrity or whatever, it's just that there's only mediocrity to celebrate. If we'd won some games recently they'd be posting a load of 'how good was this on sunday' stuff but we haven't so they have to find other stuff to post, and seeing as we've only won one trophy in 40 years many of those posts are going to be about fairly innocuous stuff.
 
I don't get the big drama about his send off to be honest. We lost 3-1 at home to a newly promoted side to make it over 2 months since we last won a game, people didn't want to hang around and applaud all the players, no big deal. He's had plenty of love from the fans including during his final game, and there's probably a 75% chance he's still here next year as a coach anyway.

On the social media stuff, you just have to remember what the point of having social media channels is. They're just trying to pump out content and get engagement - they're not deliberately celebrating mediocrity or whatever, it's just that there's only mediocrity to celebrate. If we'd won some games recently they'd be posting a load of 'how good was this on sunday' stuff but we haven't so they have to find other stuff to post, and seeing as we've only won one trophy in 40 years many of those posts are going to be about fairly innocuous stuff.

That wasn't the issue. The issue was the lack of forward planning and anticipation that that could be an outcome on the day and to plan the Coleman guard of honour etc for BEFORE the game. How could they have been so uninterested and lacking in forward planning as THAT?

It speaks volumes about this new club regime. It's not just about Coleman.
 
As an Irishman and Toffee, it should tickle me that one of my fellow countrymen is so revered at Everton. What a lovely sense of belonging that shoul evoke in me.

But it drives me nuts. Seamus was an honest plodder. That's all he was. In a properly functioning club set up to do justice to Everton's history, he'd barely be a footnote. It's quite disturbing how attached to him some people are. His PR is Goebbels-like.

He's a symptom of the Kenwright malaise. With Moyes and Prentice still in situ, nothing will change.
 
I don't get the big drama about his send off to be honest. We lost 3-1 at home to a newly promoted side to make it over 2 months since we last won a game, people didn't want to hang around and applaud all the players, no big deal. He's had plenty of love from the fans including during his final game, and there's probably a 75% chance he's still here next year as a coach anyway.

On the social media stuff, you just have to remember what the point of having social media channels is. They're just trying to pump out content and get engagement - they're not deliberately celebrating mediocrity or whatever, it's just that there's only mediocrity to celebrate. If we'd won some games recently they'd be posting a load of 'how good was this on sunday' stuff but we haven't so they have to find other stuff to post, and seeing as we've only won one trophy in 40 years many of those posts are going to be about fairly innocuous stuff.
Agreed, being blown out of all proportion. We all love Seamus. My take on him is that he was a fantastic player in his prime, followed by being a very useful player for a few years. But he hasn't really factored as a player on the pitch for the last few seasons. His last meaningful contribution really was the goal against Leeds. But you can't put a black and white tariff on that like some would like to....."it kept us up!".....well, that doesn't account for some of the other games where he struggled. And struggled badly.

All the off pitch stuff he contributed the last two years. Well, only the club really knows how invaluable that really was. My take again would be grow a pair, if they guy that sets the standards around the place can't really offer anything on the pitch anymore then someone else needs to step up and fill that gap. People being good around the training ground is one thing, but actually being a top level performer on the pitch is what this club desperately needs.

In an ideal world, he would have come on on Sunday, rolled back the years with a classic Coleman burst down the right, and drilled in the winner. But Seamus is a big boy, and he has been at Everton long enough to now that the world isn't always ideal. And the above scenario was NEVER going to happen. Same as sticking Big Nev in goal now would be a disaster.......players get to a point where its totally gone. It was badly handled by Moyes, as isolating the game people were fairly aghast that a well past it right back was being thrown on to rescue a game with 5 minutes to go. But everyone around me parked that at the specific moment and gave him a rapturous welcome. The after game thing was a damp squib, but if its the worst thing that happens to Seamus this year he will have had a very decent year
 

Similar Threads

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top