Overrated Everton Players

[formerly manx toffee]

Big Dunc

I see him further up now. A myth if ever there was one.

 

[jonesboy]

Johnny Heitinga.

And I think we as a fan base think Mirallas is better than he is, but, he is very good when in the mood. Whether that's the same as overrated, I don't know.

john heitinga was a shocker-how he got player of the season was more to his team mates and good luck--a legend in his own head--still a blue tho haha

 

[jonesboy]

McCarthy, NEA.

Hes good, very good on his day but hes never been and never will be top class

you need players like him in your team to make up for the classy slackers

 

[ArtetaMoney]

Pienaar, was only made to look good because of how good Baines is.

 

[sageyefc]

you need players like him in your team to make up for the classy slackers

Im not dismissing him because he does have a use but hes not top top class like some seem to think

 

[edge]

John Collins came with a big reputation, did f, all

 

[GlosBlue]

 

[sageyefc]

Pienaar, was only made to look good because of how good Baines is.

BS, they both made each other better because they were both great players, pienaar made baines better as much as baines made pienaar better

 

[blue4eva77]

Can't believe i didn't think of this fella.

 

[sageyefc]

Loved Manny, still get a chub on thinking of him dribbling past players in his own half

 

[Shakeitupbainesy]

Never rated that highly by anyone else but most Everton fans love him. Osman. He's never been a good player

 

[MikeH72]

Gravesen tbh. I liked the guy, but he was never Real Madrid quality. He was only really outstanding for half a season too, the rest of the time he was pretty bog standard

 

[Robertor]

Darron Gibson.

Gets better the longer he is injured.

So so wrong. Class player just never fit.

 

[mkrudden]

So so wrong. Class player just never fit.

Just my opinion mate

 

[ArtetaMoney]

BS, they both made each other better because they were both great players, pienaar made baines better as much as baines made pienaar better

Baines still is a great player, Pienaar was found out a few seasons ago.