- Status
they're the ones i disagreed with mate. I don't think any of them are overrated.
He's right though. You're allowed an opinion yes, but some people's opinions are just so woefully misinformed. If I came out and said "Messi is crap" and people rightly called me ridiculous for it, I couldn't really justify it by saying "well that's just my opinion, I'm entitled to it"
ijjysmith
Calm
Hmmm, not entirely right. Opinions are a personal thing.
See the Neymar is Crap thread for a good example. There is no wrong or right. If I think Hibbert is boss and you don't. It's not right or wrong.
But opinions can be wrong though mate, that's the thing, whilst they're peoples personal beliefs, those beliefs could still be wrong.
It's like people who believe the queen / heads of state are lizard creatures, they truly believe that, that's their opinion.. but they're still wrong.
ijjysmith
Calm
Nah. Facts and opinions are different things.
ijjysmith
Calm
Phew!
But to have an opinion you should be able to back it up with logic and reason, otherwise it's just meaningless. You can't just say "Martyn is overrated" without giving a reason why, and expect to be taken seriously in a debate
I think you can be really subjective when it comes to opinions, peoples opinions can definitely be wrong, for me anyway mate!
mythbuster
Player Valuation: £35m
You're right, yet wrong. Football is an objective thing; players and teams produce tangible performances and results. It's entirely possible to be wrong with an objective opinion.
It's not really possible to be wrong with a subjective opinion though. I might think a certain piece of art is rubbish, but somebody else might think it's great, neither of us would be wrong.
ijjysmith
Calm
American like this one!
I know what you mean and Aaron of course. It would seem nuts for someone to not rate Messi. But if they did i'm sure they'd have to have a reason.
So for the ones in this thread that Aaron doesn't agree with i'm sure the people who chose them had valid reasons. You don't have to agree of course. But they're only horrific shouts to you or Aaron in this case.
Robertor
Has left the building
Reckon McCarthy's fallen a victim of Barry being boss again, then the more flashy players being boss too. It's well known that Evertonians need someone to moan about, considering Kone's come good, Naismith and McGeady aren't playing anymore and Barry's good again mean that they need someone new to moan about. He's still one of our best players in my opinion, we'd really miss him if he got injured.
See, I chuffing LOVE a good old fashioned CDM
ijjysmith
Calm
Haha! I'm waiting for he ultimate flair defensive centre mid. Boss tackles, gets up does a rabona over the next one, step over, elbow defender in face, 30 yarder in the top corner. Goal.
The dream.
- Status
