Moyes or Glasner?

[Gilbert..]

They had their own version of Moyes in Woy Hodgson

Very similar. He came in and kept palace up if i remember correctly.
He had a decent career hodgson tbf to him.

 

[Groucho]

Who would you rather have?

Please discuss and vote in the poll.

Moyes for me

 

[Dykovski200]

Our fans would hound Glasner out within 9 months. He has one rigid way of playing and a set formation, a bit like Amorim, he’s a system manager.

Our fans will hound out anyone who steps foot into our dugout, players included

 

[GrandOldTeam]

He had a good squad at palace. He walked into a good one. Very different scenario. If he had that sort of quality here he'd hear about it on a 10 game no win run.
The flip side to that is he did improve them as a team. So patience is probably the answer there.

His 10 match run without a win has plenty of mitigating circumstances and has come the season after winning an FA Cup.

If he won us an FA Cup, and then we sold half our squad - Im not sure our fans would be particularly on his case.

He's won the europa league too and has a pedigree Lampard an Dyche didn't have - and fans tolerated their winless runs.

 

[Curtis]

The set up on Glasners first game

View attachment 340287

Usually glasner plays with one striker despite a back three , does a 3 4 2 1

 

[blueboy72]

Very similar. He came in and kept palace up if i remember correctly.
He had a decent career hodgson tbf to him.

Not so sure really, did quite well as a young manager, but was a huge failure at Blackburn, still considered a big-ish club at the time, 3 yrs on from the title. Liverpool he was a disaster and at inter Milan. And was a terrible England manager imo. If palace just wanted to survive then fine keep Hodgson, but they wanted more and while it’s now ending in tears they got into Europe and won the fa cup, which Hodgson would have never achieved. And they now have a bit more about them to attract another quality manager

 

[NorthernBlue]

Our fans would hound Glasner out within 9 months. He has one rigid way of playing and a set formation, a bit like Amorim, he’s a system manager.

He’d also throw his toys out of the pram when we sell our best players and replace them with inferior ones.

 

[blueboy72]

He’d also throw his toys out of the pram when we sell our best players and replace them with inferior ones.

I’d expect every manager to do that, apart from our current one.

 

[Ruairi77]

Not so sure really, did quite well as a young manager, but was a huge failure at Blackburn, still considered a big-ish club at the time, 3 yrs on from the title. Liverpool he was a disaster and at inter Milan. And was a terrible England manager imo. If palace just wanted to survive then fine keep Hodgson, but they wanted more and while it’s now ending in tears they got into Europe and the fa cup, which Hodgson would have never achieved. And they now have a bit more about them to attract another quality manager

By that metric, Moyes did terrible at united and in spain and went down with Sunderland and has never tried international management.
Moyes might be a slight bit better than hodgson overall but not much.
All this 'stability' crap wrecks my head.
Football revolves around a decent manager, kinda like NFL revolves around a decent QB.
Moyes is fine and if you're happy with 'fine', good for you.
I'm sick of Everton not being good.

 

[Moomin]

If anyone is in Rome this week can they let one of the Friedkins know the result of this poll please.

 

[Gilbert..]

Not so sure really, did quite well as a young manager, but was a huge failure at Blackburn, still considered a big-ish club at the time, 3 yrs on from the title. Liverpool he was a disaster and at inter Milan. And was a terrible England manager imo. If palace just wanted to survive then fine keep Hodgson, but they wanted more and while it’s now ending in tears they got into Europe and won the fa cup, which Hodgson would have never achieved. And they now have a bit more about them to attract another quality manager

Tbh i meant younger Roy. There were not that many british managers abroad back then. He did well in sweden and took switzerland to their first world cup in 20 years.

 

[blueboy72]

By that metric, Moyes did terrible at united and in spain and went down with Sunderland and has never tried international management.
Moyes might be a slight bit better than hodgson overall but not much.
All this 'stability' crap wrecks my head.
Football revolves around a decent manager, kinda like NFL revolves around a decent QB.
Moyes is fine and if you're happy with 'fine', good for you.
I'm sick of Everton not being good.

Yes I’m not a fan of Moyes and want him gone in the summer,
I was just replying to someone saying he’d had a good career and im
Not so sure

 

[Bwana]

Very similar. He came in and kept palace up if i remember correctly.
He had a decent career hodgson tbf to him.

Yep. We (Finland) were one goal shy of going to Euro2008's under him. Bunker Roy we called him. When he took over Fulham I was 100% sure he'd keep them up. And he did. A good manager and a decent bloke (if one doesn't mind the obvious thing...).

 

[Gilbert..]

His 10 match run without a win has plenty of mitigating circumstances and has come the season after winning an FA Cup.

If he won us an FA Cup, and then we sold half our squad - Im not sure our fans would be particularly on his case.

He's won the europa league too and has a pedigree Lampard an Dyche didn't have - and fans tolerated their winless runs.

He had the same run when he joined palace didnt he? Before the FA Cup.
Tbh im surprised how much ive been talking about crystal palace today.
Never thought i'd ever say that.

 

[Neiler]

Just like the home form then 7 wins in 25

What’s the head to head like between the two managers mate?