Good post and I have very similar thoughts mate, i think we need to accept hes a 10 - 15 goals a year man, i think that is the limit of his goal scoring ability. But i think we also think to one dimensionaly when it comes to strikers. Look at Mordor and how they play, Firmino in a way is their DCL, he is the decoy, he occupires centre backs, the player who creates the space, who stretches a back four when needed, the occupier in a way, then chips in with is 10-15 goals. Hes in the team ahead of the likes of Sturridge who has in the past proved a 15-20 goal a season man. Its a different way of thinking and like Mordor we have to get our heads around, thinking as a functional front three rather then just one up top.
We do need support in those positions however both left and right and up top. We need different player types. What struck me recently was Silva referring to DCL as his target man type and his preference would be a pacey forward to compliment him.
If Gylfi, Richarlison and DCL can manage 30-40 goals a season between them, the 20 goal a season striker isnt (not that we dont need different options in the front three) necessary IMO, equally anything added in those front three positions has to offer variance and end product. They can all duke it out together IMO.
Yes I agree with all of this.
I caste my mind back to 2004-5. Once Bent left the side, in favour of the more prolific Beattie the results didn't return. Bent didn't score many goals but he helped the team enormously.
For a similar reason I'd have signed Stracalursi who was a threat. Arguably our best football under
Moyes came with Cahill/Fellaini through the middle who were a menace to opponents without every scoring bundles of goals.
Don't get me wrong, if we can sign a Harry Kane, or even a Lukaku then I'd do that. I think it's extremely unlikely though. And frankly if we had Lukaku I'd find a way to play 2 up front, as he would have scored bundles more goals with Calvert Lewin alongside him (he'd be the perfect foil for Rom).
I agree with Silva too. For me we need to find a lad with pace, who can play across the front 3 (so if DCL form dips, he needs a break, he's injured) he can fill in and also in some games someone who is capable of playing alongside Calvert Lewin if we are chasing the game.
That player is completely different to both Niasse & Tosun.
I still think Calvert Lewin will score between 10-15 league goals next season, which if done alongside driving defences back will be absolutely fine for me. He may even surprise us all and continue to improve his finishing.