Allardyce v Silva Conundrum

[4737carlin]

Silva gots my vote. We need exciting football Dyche & Moyes do not give us that. We need to be more aggressive and score a lot more goals.. this combination will give us more fans and more revenue which means bigger signings.

More fans? were sold out every week mate, Silva is exactly what we don't need, after 90 minutes we need to have scored more goals then the opponent, something Silva couldn't deliver at Watford or Hull, which is why one sacked him and the other got relegated

 

[Bob Latchford]

TO BE FAIR, we DID replace Moyes. We had an 'identity' and a thought about how to go forward as a club under Martinez. It's just that a) the wheels fell off after the Arsenal match and then b) it became blatantly apparent he had 0 idea of how to handle both sides of the pitch and c) then became clear that the passing back and forth had no idea how to ACTUALLY break down teams.

The explosive, fast break counter attacking team in his first year was fantastic and what MOST would probably like. ALLLLL the club had to do is get someone with the same type of ideas with attacking but had ANY idea of how to make a defense work. Instead, they figuratively blew everything up to start all over again for no reason wiht Koeman.


*edit* and to tie this all in to Fat Sam vs Silva, Im not exactly thinking Silva is any better than Martinez as they have conceded the 2nd most goals this year.

Yes we did replace Moyes but as it turned out it was not successful. My point was more a retrospective yap as to us not replacing him successfully. The first season under Martinez looked like a step forward but when he finally put his stamp on the team his limitations were exposed. Arguments against in hindsight for RM and RK seem obvious now and they both ultimately failed badly and now we have BFS. I really don’t know about Silva. Would he have done any better with Watford had they not got the injuries they got? They looked very good initially but the goals against, relegation with Hull and wheels coming off with Watford are all worrying trends.

 

[Prevenger17]

Dyche

 

[GrandOldTeam]

"Keep Allardyce indefinitely" isn't doing well.

Can change votes, be interesting to see if a run of results changes it.

 

[GrandOldTeam]

Bump.

 

[4737carlin]

Silva ain't the answer which is why he gets sacked and unlike Sam takes teams down

 

[d4kyxx]

Weird how we were willing to pay 10m for him as we clearly liked him

Now he’s available for free yet we don’t want to know

Do we have any idea what we are doing

 

[jayden28]

Silva in please,end of discussion.

 

[4737carlin]

Silva in please,end of discussion.

No thanks

 

[faddy the blue]

Appoint Silva to further illustrate how we are the most confused club on this earth. Keep changing your managers and make 360 degree turns with their footballing philosophies, confuse the players, declare more players from previous regime as "not good enough" and spend another 100-200M on the "good enough" players the next manager wants. However, the incompetent DoF oveeseeing the plundering of money and wasting talent keeps his job and a deluded billionaire owner who thinks he is really bulding something will keep on hoping he has employed the right personnel and has his "Fab Four".

Utter shambles this club.

 

[jayden28]

No thanks

Let's just keep gravy tits then as he's doing such a great job.

 

[nsno-chris]

Sack and appoint my toilet deposit from before, it’ll do a better job

 

[4737carlin]

Let's just keep gravy tits then as he's doing such a great job.

No let's get a good manager for once ? People are only saying Silva because they have no idea where to turn to next but he has nothing going for him in this league

 

[Tennessee Blue Mike]

Get Silva in immediately.

 

[Dabluez]

Get Silva in immediately.

The problem is whoever follows Fat Sham is on a hiding to nothing. The media love the sloth and you could bring in Guardiola or Mourinho and it would be still harsh on poor Sam. They will have the knives out for whoever has the temerity to replace the obese one.

Jose did the right thing he wanted the United job but had the sense to let Van Gaal and Moyesy fail before he took the job on. Look at today it was all about the players letting the Fat F@@k down and nothing was about the fact that he has a truly horrendous record as a manager.

No one with any sense will want to replace Lardarse.