After Season 2025-26, Moyes OUT or IN

[jceverton]

Dyche was a needs-must appointment. I never despised him because the club was an ash heap when he came in and burned from there. Points deductions, impending administration, absentee owners, the spectre of 777/Textor... Dyche was always the least of our problems to me. Indeed, he was a positive in the circumstances for most of his tenure. Context is everything. He was critical in our survival as a top tier club. But he had to go when he went - and should have been relieved the previous summer if our competent professionals had their ears to the ground and feet under the table.

But Moyes now just seems a totally needless exercise in self-flagellation. We don't need him in any way, shape, or form. He's a force of negativity and narrow horizons.

Get him gone.

Agreed and we're in danger of having the same situation now with Moyes. He needs to be booted now, we keep him and end up struggling next season and we are back in same scenario.

 

[preposterousvelios]

With such a clear large majority of fans being Moyes out and Kinnear and the club seemingly oblivious, is there any way for us to make fans feelings known?

Hard now that season is over and harder again considering how much media in this country loves Moyes - Almost all coverage he gets is positive.

 

[Saint Domingo]

With such a clear large majority of fans being Moyes out and Kinnear and the club seemingly oblivious, is there any way for us to make fans feelings known?

Hard now that season is over and harder again considering how much media in this country loves Moyes - Almost all coverage he gets is positive.

Somehow, somewhere, there’s an Everton fan dusting off his spray paint can and balaclava.

Moyes out, Guardiola in

 

[YMJ]

I have given him all season and the players have not shown enough during the last 6 games. I don’t care about poor decisions and injuries. He has not used the squad well enough throughout the season to rest his chosen few at key times and keep the team fresh and firing to the end of the season.

I am not a Moyes out under any circumstances.
I am a Moyes out if we can identify a better replacement.
But I am a Moyes out.

 

[Caolam]

I have given him all season and the players have not shown enough during the last 6 games. I don’t care about poor decisions and injuries. He has not used the squad well enough throughout the season to rest his chosen few at key times and keep the team fresh and firing to the end of the season.

I am not a Moyes out under any circumstances.
I am a Moyes out if we can identify a better replacement.
But I am a Moyes out.

I really can’t see any of us being a Moyes out under any circumstances, we all know this club has the capacity to make a bad situation worse. There would appear to be a number of good managers out there looking for a good club to take forward. I fear that if we sit on our hands and don’t be proactive we will find ourselves struggling to replace Moyes at the end of next season. He will have brought in his type of player: older steady work horses with no sell on value and no reason to leave the club because they will be on the best terms they can get.
If we are going to move on we need someone who can get us to the next level, we need a manager who looks to win every game, who gives us a chance. Moyes was the right choice for the job of stopping the slide with his risk adverse tactics and selection, now is a different time, we need to buy players who want to win, we need a management that gives them a chance to win.

 

[Cels]

Full disclosure and transparency... I voted for Moysie to stay.

 

[davek]

Seeing Sunderland come through and get that EL place was like a dagger to the heart.

That underlined the opportunity that was there this season that was spurned by this manager.

It cant ever be forgiven.

He basically shat the bed over getting that Euro spot and that transmitted to the players too. Then he blamed the players for it.

He has no heart for anything other than defending his own record and his own bank balance.

 

[catcherintherye]

For me the foundations are a well rounded squad where the wage bill is not suffocating the club. We have been paying too much money to rubbish players for too long, some have been moved on but some are still hanging around.

We cannot go into next season with the same backline as today, with no players capable of rotating in the front line and two strikers who maybe if you combined their best attributes would just about make a Premier league quality player.

Those are the foundations for me, throwing new managers at the problem isn't going to make it better until player recruitment is sorted.

Look at Sunderland, at the top of the club they have a plan for the future, like Brighton and Brentford they have a recruitment policy and they executed it over the summer. We ended up with Michael Keane playing the majority of the season and our best fit centre back playing right back. That is not all on Moyes however he cannot shirk the responsibility for the end of season collapse.

So better recruitment?

Could that be done with a different manager I suppose is the question.

 

[jazzy]

Full disclosure and transparency... I voted for Moysie to stay.

This may come as a shock but for the sake of transparency I voted OUT!

I salute your candour and honesty and genuinely hope that I have to eat humble pie and prostrate myself at the altar of the Moyesiah next season, but I fear not.

 

[Number_25]

I needed a day to cool off after yesterday. While it's frustrating that we threw away Europe, and Moyes definitely shares the blame for that, the reality is that our squad over the last 10 games just didn't have the quality to compete.

We made decent progress this season, and after a solid 7/10 transfer window last summer, we took a step forward. However, we're still 4 to 6 players short, with at least 4 needing to be immediate, guaranteed starters. Looking ahead, teams that did qualify for Europe will likely struggle with the extra workload next year, much like Forest and Palace have this season.

The opportunity is there for us. Moyes has done just enough to earn one more season to capitalise on it, but the moment European qualification looks out of reach, it's time to part ways.

 

[jazzy]

I have given him all season and the players have not shown enough during the last 6 games. I don’t care about poor decisions and injuries. He has not used the squad well enough throughout the season to rest his chosen few at key times and keep the team fresh and firing to the end of the season.

I am not a Moyes out under any circumstances.
I am a Moyes out if we can identify a better replacement.
But I am a Moyes out.

You don't think Glasner or Iraola to name 2 managers readily available would be a "better replacement"

 

[jazzy]

I needed a day to cool off after yesterday. While it's frustrating that we threw away Europe, and Moyes definitely shares the blame for that, the reality is that our squad over the last 10 games just didn't have the quality to compete.

We made decent progress this season, and after a solid 7/10 transfer window last summer, we took a step forward. However, we're still 4 to 6 players short, with at least 4 needing to be immediate, guaranteed starters. Looking ahead, teams that did qualify for Europe will likely struggle with the extra workload next year, much like Forest and Palace have this season.

The opportunity is there for us. Moyes has done just enough to earn one more season to capitalise on it, but the moment European qualification looks out of reach, it's time to part ways.

What is this mythical progress that you are talking about?

 

[Number_25]

What is this mythical progress that you are talking about?

A season where we weren't in the bottom 3 for large parts of it.

 

[PhilRegan]

I needed a day to cool off after yesterday. While it's frustrating that we threw away Europe, and Moyes definitely shares the blame for that, the reality is that our squad over the last 10 games just didn't have the quality to compete.

We made decent progress this season, and after a solid 7/10 transfer window last summer, we took a step forward. However, we're still 4 to 6 players short, with at least 4 needing to be immediate, guaranteed starters. Looking ahead, teams that did qualify for Europe will likely struggle with the extra workload next year, much like Forest and Palace have this season.

The opportunity is there for us. Moyes has done just enough to earn one more season to capitalise on it, but the moment European qualification looks out of reach, it's time to part ways.

I fear that this relaxed approach is why we're still talking about Europe and not competing in it.

The problem with hoping that other teams struggle and relying on that as a pathway to our own succes is that other clubs simply aren't ran like us and won't allow us to make up ground . The time is now , we won't get a better chance for Europe than this year .

Palace about to win a trophy , forest semi final in Europe, ill swap to their struggle please .

 

[jazzy]

A season where we weren't in the bottom 3 for large parts of it.

Wow, this is some definition of progress when we maintain the same position as last season and went out of the cups without a whimper and the football was completely turgid