2025/26 Season Rating

[MikeH72]

Well, I consider it the end of our season right now regardless of which teams surpass us on the final day. 49 points is very very poor in my opinion, it wasn’t good enough under the former manager, and it’s not good enough under this one. Right now we look a worse team than we did 12 months ago under the same manager. The capitulation in the last month of this season has been frankly shameful and I don’t agree with our esteemed CEO’s rewriting of history that the objective was always to simply not be staring down the barrel of the relegation gun. What do you rate the season overall?

 

[Nymzee]

Will wait till we batter Spurs 7-0, results go our way, and we finish 8th before voting thank you.

 

[MikeH72]

Will wait till we batter Spurs 7-0, results go our way, and we finish 8th before voting thank you.

I like your optimism of a clean sheet with Tarks and Keano in there.

 

[Nymzee]

I like your optimism of a clean sheet with Tarks and Keano in there.

*7-2

 

[Toffe3m4n]

4.

Absolutely pissed away a great opportunity to get some European footy next season considering a number of positive results we had been able to pick up earlier on.. mostly away from home.

The home form itself was also just utterly unacceptable. The footy itself also largely crap.

No discernible progress made.. again.

 

[Miked1e]

I went for 2. The only reason it's not a 1 is because we went into the last couple of months safe from any relegation threat.

Other than that it seems zero to little progress, confusing but predictable lines ups and in game management, still many players at the club I never want to see again, poor recruitment in the main and same old Everton as bottle jobs.

Not many positives to take out of this season tbh.

I look forward to a few months off with other football to 'enjoy' watching.

 

[neil999]

Been so weird...a month ago it looked really good

 

[Jebus_lives]

Well, I consider it the end of our season right now regardless of which teams surpass us on the final day. 49 points is very very poor in my opinion, it wasn’t good enough under the former manager, and it’s not good enough under this one. Right now we look a worse team than we did 12 months ago under the same manager. The capitulation in the last month of this season has been frankly shameful and I don’t agree with our esteemed CEO’s rewriting of history that the objective was always to simply not be staring down the barrel of the relegation gun. What do you rate the season overall?

5.

Odd really, as had we shown just a hint of ambition, it could've been about an 8.

Ultimately mid table, lack of effective squad development, woeful results in the cup, and multiple failed opportunities missed probably drops it down to a 4/5.

 

[Dddddd]

3
Points for no relegation scrap

Out of cups early, awful home form and mostly boring football

 

[MikeH72]

Shouldn’t be lost to history that Anus himself said top 10 and cup runs were the aim. 6 weeks ago we were 6th and in pole position not just for a top half finish but for Europe. If you’d told me we’d pick up 0 wins and 3 points in that time I would’ve called you a loon. We can’t paper over how disastrous this last quarter of the season has been.

 

[welshtoffee]

3 due to our chronic home form

 

[Duncan’s Pigeon Loft]

4. A huge opportunity missed to qualify for Europe and really kick on. The form since the last international break has been a disgrace. Another big summer ahead

 

[Toffeeslam]

5

No relegation battle which after the last few years is positive

Last 6 games are an unmitigated disaster considering the opportunity we gave ourselves

Overall bang average at best

 

[Blue peter]

Can’t recall exactly but off the top of my head I’ve never felt that we have looked particular great or comfortable when beating teams (Forest both games maybe) but a lot of our games have been on a knife edge and so we have rode our luck at times.

I was prepared to wait until the end of the season to assess as results can compensate for the above bit now that we are not getting those results and we are slipping down the league, it’s been a poor season. I generously marked 5 but probably should have gone with the consensus of 4.

 

[MikeH72]

5.

Odd really, as had we shown just a hint of ambition, it could've been about an 8.

Ultimately mid table, lack of effective squad development, woeful results in the cup, and multiple failed opportunities missed probably drops it down to a 4/5.

Top 10 and cup runs is what Anus said was the objective this season. So comfortably bottom half and straight out of the cups is by his own definition a complete failure on every count. Come to think of it, I think my 4 might be generous.