Titus Bramble
Best centre half to grace the Premier League
No one's made more mistakes and give more penalties and dangerous free kicks away than Hibbert and Neville, neither our even close to Barkley's talent yet both in the team every week, that puts that argument to bed, Moyes doesn't like players with flare because in 10 years he's signed 2 for money Arteta and Pienarr , neither are now Officially Everton players , Moyes prefare's the defence first approach and players like Jack Rodwell, Darren Gibson, and Fellaini, the proof in this argument is that our left back has been our main source of creativity for a couple of years now, We get results with Moyes but it's boring negative football , which doesn't include a Ross Barkley, and us fans are now used to it
How can you compare Hibbert and Neville (two full backs, one can play defensive mid at a push) with Barkley, whose job is, or will be in a few years, to dominate the midfield and drive forward? They are completely different players so saying 1 has more talent than the other is a complete non argument.