bluestevon
Player Valuation: £80m
So you think the LotR TV series is bad not because of bad writing, directing or a greedy parent company trying to squeeze what they can from a franchise, but because of the inclusion of a few people of colour and women in certain roles?
A fantasy world should be immersing, a known fantasy world with a meticulous lore should definitely be an immersive experience. A company deliberately going out the way to destroy canon, lore and essentially across the entire show make it multi diverse for every race makes it almost laughable mate.
The bad writing and atrocious dialogue alone as enough to sink the show, but as this thread is about woke rather than a writing thread, it's the pertinent part.
They chose Tolkien for the same reason they've used marvel, star wars etc as vehicles to push "a show for modern audiences" "reflecting the world we live in" and frankly it's because they thought the fans would lap up any old dross they served up allowing them to try to imprint their own personal beliefs.
For context House of the dragon included many strong well written female characters, several major characters are black, it doesn't break immersion, because the characters have purpose beyond virtue signalling. And the initial fan reaction from some very very quickly went away.
Thees always the defence of 'hur, it's fantasy can't they be anything they want", and yup, you want that write a new series, don't take an existing IP beloved by millions and trash it. Tolkien would be spinning in his grave
