They don't mate. We've had a higher average attendance than them every season since 2012.
http://www.worldfootball.net/attendance/eng-premier-league-2016-2017/1/
We also had a higher average attendance than them during the mid-1990s, when they were good and we were not, and also, curiously, when we were really crap in 1999/2000 and 2000/2001.
There were also numerous seasons in 2000s when we had a higher average attendance despite having a smaller ground with worse facilities.
Not to mention our away support.
I agree with you regarding the fanbase. I still consider villa to be a big club, but not necessarily above Everton. Credit to the Geordies last night for their following to Brighton in their televised game. I think when we get our new stadium and hopefully the fantastic location and facilities, other fans (maybe not dean Saunders) will once again recognise what a big club Everton are.[Poor language removed] waving over who is a bigger club is cringeworthy, leave it to the millenial cringe merchants in the daily mail comments section.
However if forced to give an opinion on how big a club is I'd base it on the size of their fanbase and not on their trophy count.
Trophies = how successful you are
You can have a huge a fanbase and still not win trophies.
Spurs are ridiculously massive, their waiting list is huge, villa also probably have more fans than us due to being the biggest team in a bigger city than Liverpool.
Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.