Current Affairs Ukraine

Status
Not open for further replies.
For our friend who seems to dislike Ireland, 210,000 from the SOUTH volunteered in WW1 35,000 dead including my relation.

How dare you say that I or any Irish Evertonian has an agenda against Britain.
Haha! Coming from Liverpool, my ancestry is STEEPED with Irish forbears. Back two generations and you hit the names: McCormick, McConnell, Coughlan. And others of their family who on the censuses showed they were originally from Ireland.

So to say I dislike Ireland is totally 100% wide of the mark. It is your attitude re Hamburg and Dresden that I take exception to.
 
Well explain yourself properly then. Previous posts have been heavily slanted towards Hamburg and Dresden.

Both legitimate targets with a population that provided the workforce that provided the military hardware for the front line that would kill allied soldiers.

Notwithstanding the fact that I have researched the 'other' side in WW2 for over 40 years, with several outcomes, I'm with Patton when he said: '...The object of war is not to die for your country but to make the other [Poor language removed] die for his...' Unfortunately, that is the brutal truth, and appertains to WW2, with particular reference to my previous paragraph.
Look, I would like to stay friendly with a fellow Blue. There were atrocities on all sides. The Holocaust unforgivable.

However, bombing and incinerating thousands of innocent civilians is just wrong.

I can accept accidental civilians being killed in warfare but I cannot accept massive bombing of civilians.

I have absolutely no anti British agenda. I am for peace.
 
Speaking from experience here. I’ve been unfortunate to have been involved in two major conflicts. I’ve seen and heard some nasty stuff.

My experience as part of ground-air Ops in Gorazde in Bosnia made me question everything and ultimately led to me quitting military service.

War changes people, it lets loose the demons inside people and without proper control can quickly and easily get out of control. Some of things I saw in Bosnia I won’t repeat on this forum. But it is what it is…War is the fkin pits.

If it comes to war then decency and humanity are the first victims, believe me.
 
Ah yeah, because you were the victims and never aggressors in both world wars. Can give you the examples if you want, but you know your history so you should know them. :)

Definitely no civilian casualties and baseless slaughter by the great British army, in either World War, as well! No siree.
Going back hundreds of years, the British were the agressors in countless areas of the world. I'm perfectly aware of that. Go check the British machinations that led to the start of the Zulu war, for starters. An absolute disgrace! I'm taking issue with the fact that a certain poster has lingered on Hamburg and Dresden, that's all, and in so doing, appears to have a bias against the British (while not saying a thing about the German atrocities in WW2 I listed). That's all I'm saying.
 
Haha! Coming from Liverpool, my ancestry is STEEPED with Irish forbears. Back two generations and you hit the names: McCormick, McConnell, Coughlan. And others of their family who on the censuses showed they were originally from Ireland.

So to say I dislike Ireland is totally 100% wide of the mark. It is your attitude re Hamburg and Dresden that I take exception to.
Mate my "attitude" to Hamburg and Dresden is horror at slaughter.

Forgive me if you take exception.

Btw it is spelt MC Cormack
 
Going back hundreds of years, the British were the agressors in countless areas of the world. I'm perfectly aware of that. Go check the British machinations that led to the start of the Zulu war, for starters. An absolute disgrace! I'm taking issue with the fact that a certain poster has lingered on Hamburg and Dresden, that's all, and in so doing, appears to have a bias against the British (while not saying a thing about the German atrocities in WW2 I listed). That's all I'm saying.
The thing is we've talked about the German atrocities quite at length here already and it kinda looked like whataboutism (similar to the "but America did so and so"), instead of what you were aiming for.

Maybe that's just me though.
 
Speaking from experience here. I’ve been unfortunate to have been involved in two major conflicts. I’ve seen and heard some done nasty stuff.

My experience as part of ground-air Ops in Gorazde in Bosnia made me question everything and ultimately led to me quitting military service.

War changes people, it lets loose the demons inside people and without proper control can quickly and easily get out of control. Some of things I saw in Bosnia I won’t repeat on this forum. But it is what it is…War is the fkin pits.

If it comes to war then decency, humanity are the first victims, believe me.
Great post mate.

I know Irishmen who served during the Bosnia- Croatia- Serbia wars. With the UN but saw terrible things. What we are seeing today in Ukraine is the same. My fear is escalation
 
Look, I would like to stay friendly with a fellow Blue. There were atrocities on all sides. The Holocaust unforgivable.

However, bombing and incinerating thousands of innocent civilians is just wrong.

I can accept accidental civilians being killed in warfare but I cannot accept massive bombing of civilians.

I have absolutely no anti British agenda. I am for peace.
Good. Then if you read one of my earlier posts, I simply said in the 'modern' war (i.e. WW2 particularly) the civilian was an integral part of the whole military infrastructure, in that they provided the workforce that built the military hardware for the war to continue to be prosecuted. That applied to us as well as them. My father was called up 3 times in WW2, and each time the company he worked for (the ATE on Edge Lane, later to become Plesseys) blocked his call-up as he was classed as being in a reserve occupation given his skills. I'm quite honest to admit he was every bit a legitimate target as the men on front line duties. That's all I'm saying. It wasn't a Waterloo June 1815 scenario, by WW2 it was something completely different. And we have to understand and accept that. We may totally deplore it (as I do), but it is a trueism...
 
Great post mate.

I know Irishmen who served during the Bosnia- Croatia- Serbia wars. With the UN but saw terrible things. What we are seeing today in Ukraine is the same. My fear is escalation
In Ukraine now we are going to see something akin to a WWII style conflict.

Russia has shown it can’t fight a war of mechanised manoeuvre, instead it will revert to mass artillery barrages followed by slow advance with armour finally followed by mass infantry assaults on well dug in Ukranian positions.

Ukraine needs Storming Norman to lead them - that guy was an absolute war-fighting genius.
 
Speaking from experience here. I’ve been unfortunate to have been involved in two major conflicts. I’ve seen and heard some nasty stuff.

My experience as part of ground-air Ops in Gorazde in Bosnia made me question everything and ultimately led to me quitting military service.

War changes people, it lets loose the demons inside people and without proper control can quickly and easily get out of control. Some of things I saw in Bosnia I won’t repeat on this forum. But it is what it is…War is the fkin pits.

If it comes to war then decency and humanity are the first victims, believe me.
There's soldiers on every side of the divide who enjoy (and enjoyed) their work too much; we're not talking about general military life, but rather destroying things.

It's no different to the boys and girls who take pleasure from vandalising, breaking things and causing pain: too many soldiers take pleasure from destruction.

Wretchedly, this includes destroying people rather than material objects - taking lives. Murdering. When men (and now women) become desensitised, it's too easy.

They're not people at the end of the sights; they're enemies, mere objects to erase if required to do so and that's where the depravity comes from.

Like you say, combat and war is the pits, which is why it's compartmentalised.
 
Going back hundreds of years, the British were the agressors in countless areas of the world. I'm perfectly aware of that. Go check the British machinations that led to the start of the Zulu war, for starters. An absolute disgrace! I'm taking issue with the fact that a certain poster has lingered on Hamburg and Dresden, that's all, and in so doing, appears to have a bias against the British (while not saying a thing about the German atrocities in WW2 I listed). That's all I'm saying.
How dare you accuse me of bias against Britain.

I hate all war especially when civilians are killed. I think I need to get off this thread as you are just doing my head in.

The civilian death toll in the two cities was over 70,000. Nothing justifies that.

Nothing justifies nuking Hiroshima and Nagasaki.

Nothing justifies what is going on in Ukraine.

If you are not prepared to have a polite debate, fine.
 
Going back hundreds of years, the British were the agressors in countless areas of the world. I'm perfectly aware of that. Go check the British machinations that led to the start of the Zulu war, for starters. An absolute disgrace! I'm taking issue with the fact that a certain poster has lingered on Hamburg and Dresden, that's all, and in so doing, appears to have a bias against the British (while not saying a thing about the German atrocities in WW2 I listed). That's all I'm saying.
In January 1946, Major Cortez F. Enloe, a surgeon in the USAAF who worked on the United States Strategic Bombing Survey (USSBS), said that the fire effects of the atomic bomb dropped on Nagasaki "were not nearly as bad as the effects of the R.A.F. raids on Hamburg on July 27th 1943". He estimated that more than 40,000 people died in Hamburg.
 
Mate my "attitude" to Hamburg and Dresden is horror at slaughter.

Forgive me if you take exception.

Btw it is spelt MC Cormack
From what I know, 'mack' and 'mick' are both offshoots of Gaelic, and so are found in both Ireland and Scotland. My branch of the family with the 'mick' were definitely of Irish descent.
Family history is fascinating (digressing from the main theme as I am). On my father's side there were Waldrons from Co. Mayo.
 
Mate, Mac. means son of. A daughter is ní. In Serbo Croatia it is --ic. That is why so many Slavs have names ending in ic

Mc and Mac are interchangeable although I use the former in English. Ní is short for iníon which means daughter.

So my daughter is ní my surname in Irish, but Mc in English :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top