nick_waters
Player Valuation: £950k
What else
is he going to say. Rhol definitely won’t be a 10. And we need a proper number 6 next season imo
I call him “Tim” so he doesn’t get me many points in scrabble ..
Rather sell him and sign someone with a longer and simpler name
He's definitely not one of our best players when he plays, at least not every time. The fact you're listing about 3 games from his nearly 20 says enough.
You jump to his defence as if I'm saying I want him shot dead - he's just average on a good day and works well when we're playing to counter or against tired legs, but hasn't shown he's a solid enough midfielder technically (yet) as he doesn't have the awareness for it and is prone to falling asleep. I don't hate him or anything, just bizarre how we've had a lot of players show more and be blasted down, but for Tim it's as if he's Big Iniesta all of a sudden. Hate me all you want for it, but at this point in time he is still upper championship and would boss games there. Maybe he'll learn and do it in the Prem for us too, but it's a maybe right now.
Re: the comparison with Garner - Garner had played a ton more games at varying levels at Tim's age and was already showing he's great. We sadly had Dyche and even then JG was still showing he's a baller. The fact people say he's still young at 22-23 is also pretty funny - in a way, he is, but in many other ways many teams have players U20 look much better and play week in-week out. Tom Davies, of all people, was a first team regular in the Prem at 18-19. Tim was 7th choice at Villa or something at that age.
That said, it'd be mad to sell him, he'd be a good addition to have around as he has his strengths. If we SOMEHOW make it to Europe he will absolutely bully most teams there too.
Good player, definitly a good squad player.
Love his old school throwback tackles..
He will progress you up the pitch well.
2/3 of a player, he hasn't got the final third in his locker.
It comes down to what you want out of the lad..
Selling now would be silly business, unless you received an offer that matches what you class as good a return.
Would we use that money wisely ?
If we want a return on Alcaraz, he could be gone in the summer given his contract.
Gana might not get an extension, so that could be 3 gone from one area.
You dont want the CM to suddenly be a priority over Fb's and Striker.
Love his old school throwback tackles..
He will progress you up the pitch well.
2/3 of a player, he hasn't got the final third in his locker.
It comes down to what you want out of the lad..
Selling now would be silly business, unless you received an offer that matches what you class as good a return.
Would we use that money wisely ?
If we want a return on Alcaraz, he could be gone in the summer given his contract.
Gana might not get an extension, so that could be 3 gone from one area.
You dont want the CM to suddenly be a priority over Fb's and Striker.
I’d keep Myko and O’Brien as full
Backs and Beto and Barry as our strikers for next season . Because we may not use the money wisely in the summer
Currently 6 no? Not including HA
You've lost me !!I’d keep Myko and O’Brien as full
Backs and Beto and Barry as our strikers for next season . Because we may not use the money wisely in the summer
We will have had a good 12months with the recruitment team in place to find Fb's, I don't want anything effecting those positions.
Midfield is not a priority, don't make it the pinpoint..
Paul Rideout
Player Valuation: £40m
Irrespective, there is no way this kid should be going anywhere for close to what we paid for him. I’d expect us to be doubling our money tbh.
Sean0925
Player Valuation: £500k
What he needs to work on more than anything else is consistency. A lot of us say they see a player there because you see him do some really good stuff as a physical midfielder then just completely mess it up due to a lack of awareness of whats around him or make rash decisions. It'd be a bigger sign of improvement to me if he could play consistent games without being overly bad.
You said let’s not sell Tim and “would they use the money wisely? “ but you think they will use the money wisely to buy full backs and strikers
Kevsleftpeg
Player Valuation: £35m
On his good days he has been MOTM. In what way is that average? Players progress at different rates. You seem to not understand that. Check out the comments from fans on this sight after his best games this season. Most player thought Garner was a nothing player who hid from the ball until fairly recently. I’d say Tim has played better this season than Garner did for the first half of last season. You just seem wilfully blind. Upper championship? He’s got a shed load of minutes for a team that is 9th. What planet are you on?
