Current Affairs The Would Be Emperor Has No Clothes (aka POTUS 47)

Status
Not open for further replies.
You seem like one of the VERY few who engage in civil discussion, and for that I thank you.

I wasn't aware that I was challenged to post videos - I don't have them and really can't be arsed to find them if they're readily available. It's not disingenuous as I stated from the off that 'just because something looks like it, doesn't necessarily mean it is'. The photo looks like a hatful of Nazi salutes - it's not, but it looks it. WHICH IS MY POINT.


This forum is a hate filled, self-serving echo chamber where if the party line isn't towed - you're bombarded with abuse from the #BE NICE gang.


I have an OPINION - 'AN OPINION' that Elon Musk wouldn't be stupid enough to do an actual Roman salute twice live on TV. Yes it looks like it, of course it does, I don't believe that's his intention. For this, i'm called effing stupid, a clown, thick as a carrier bag - from the very people who claim to be the morally superior.


GRAND OLD TEAM.
Our priority has always remained the same – to provide the very best place on the web for fans worldwide to congregate and discuss Everton Football Club. GrandOldTeam prides itself on offering Everton fans a place for intelligent and respectful debate.

What a joke.
I’m not reading all that
 
You seem like one of the VERY few who engage in civil discussion, and for that I thank you.

I wasn't aware that I was challenged to post videos - I don't have them and really can't be arsed to find them if they're readily available. It's not disingenuous as I stated from the off that 'just because something looks like it, doesn't necessarily mean it is'. The photo looks like a hatful of Nazi salutes - it's not, but it looks it. WHICH IS MY POINT.


This forum is a hate filled, self-serving echo chamber where if the party line isn't towed - you're bombarded with abuse from the #BE NICE gang.


I have an OPINION - 'AN OPINION' that Elon Musk wouldn't be stupid enough to do an actual Roman salute twice live on TV. Yes it looks like it, of course it does, I don't believe that's his intention. For this, i'm called effing stupid, a clown, thick as a carrier bag - from the very people who claim to be the morally superior.


GRAND OLD TEAM.
Our priority has always remained the same – to provide the very best place on the web for fans worldwide to congregate and discuss Everton Football Club. GrandOldTeam prides itself on offering Everton fans a place for intelligent and respectful debate.

What a joke.
But surely you can see why people don’t think you’re arguing in good faith.

First, simply taking Musk at his word on the matter seems incredibly naive.

Second, a person having their right arm extended is not the same thing as the gesture in question. That’s why the video of the images you linked would be valuable. They would provide context that a still image simply cannot.

Also, as I’ve mentioned multiple times, and even linked a video, this isn’t his first time using something that perfectly mimics a white supremacist gesture in public. Also, they were two unique gestures, not just repeating the same one where it could possibly be explained away as some unusual mannerism of his. What say you to that? When do these things stop being a coincidence?
 
If somebody kicked you in the nuts would you say 'whether it was a kick in the nuts or not, only the guy kicking knows'?
Obviously not, because I can feel that I have been kicked in the nuts. That would be a fact.

Now, if you asked did he mean to kick me in the nuts or kick me on the cock, only the person that kicked me would know
 
Obviously not, because I can feel that I have been kicked in the nuts. That would be a fact.

Now, if you asked did he mean to kick me in the nuts or kick me on the cock, only the person that kicked me would know
so it is about the minutiae of the act then? I suppose we could assess the character of the kicker to make a better judgement. Does he for example regularly support other nut kickers? If he does I would say it is beyond a reasonable doubt that it was a kick in the nuts
 
You seem like one of the VERY few who engage in civil discussion, and for that I thank you.

I wasn't aware that I was challenged to post videos - I don't have them and really can't be arsed to find them if they're readily available. It's not disingenuous as I stated from the off that 'just because something looks like it, doesn't necessarily mean it is'. The photo looks like a hatful of Nazi salutes - it's not, but it looks it. WHICH IS MY POINT.


This forum is a hate filled, self-serving echo chamber where if the party line isn't towed - you're bombarded with abuse from the #BE NICE gang.


I have an OPINION - 'AN OPINION' that Elon Musk wouldn't be stupid enough to do an actual Roman salute twice live on TV. Yes it looks like it, of course it does, I don't believe that's his intention. For this, i'm called effing stupid, a clown, thick as a carrier bag - from the very people who claim to be the morally superior.


GRAND OLD TEAM.
Our priority has always remained the same – to provide the very best place on the web for fans worldwide to congregate and discuss Everton Football Club. GrandOldTeam prides itself on offering Everton fans a place for intelligent and respectful debate.

What a joke.

Which is a bad point.

You cannot compare a photo with a video. There is a video of Musk doing this (Twice), all you provided in comparison is a still photo with no context.

Let me go to a football analogy we know well here. Allen was sent off against Newcastle, what we saw was that when the ref came to the VAR screen there was a still image of contact, it looked bad and was therefore sent off. Now if we watch the video of that tackle, there is no force and he was in control the whole time. It wasn't the case (If I remember it right) but the incident could also have missed that the ball was got first, which you cannot see from a still image after this has happened.

It looked like a Nazi salute in a still photo and it certainly looked like it in a video, it is added to the fact that his actions and words over the past year or so have been very much bordering on fascism. The reactions of the people around him is also very telling.

You are allowed to have the opinion but I think you are missing/ignoring very pertinent pieces of information that very much lends itself to the idea that this was meant as exactly it was seen to be.

You also based your opinion in the fact that he denied it, again not a very good point to make and is easily pulled apart, which people have done.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top