Rodwell replacement?

[james2805]

Honest question mate. Are you an everton man?

Yes mate, and as an Everton man I know that Dempsey would be a vast improvement on the Cahill of the last 2 years, and that Dempsey is actually a better footballing player than Cahill.

Sorry that I don't live my life in blue tinted aussie 'hero' loving specs.

 

[bluebottle]

Laughable.

Dempsey at Fulham from 2007:

157 (27) Appearances 50 Goals - Thats just in the league.

Cahill at Everton from 2004! :

210 (16) 56 - 6 more goals in the league with 3 more years to do it in?


Wow guys, the stats really back you guys up. And Dempsey was only more recently moved more prominantly behind the striker.

Also originally the comparison was made with regards to impact on the team. Cahill in his prime was pretty prolific. Noone is arguing that Dempsey isnt as well. Would Dempsey make us a better passing side ala Pienaar or would he just be adding goals? (no bad thing)

 

[Joao Moutinho]

Yes mate, and as an Everton man I know that Dempsey would be a vast improvement on the Cahill of the last 2 years, and that Dempsey is actually a better footballing player than Cahill.

Sorry that I don't live my life in blue tinted aussie 'hero' loving specs.

Cahill may have been poor last season but he's still a hero

on yer bike lad

 

[james2805]

Also originally the comparison was made with regards to impact on the team. Cahill in his prime was pretty prolific. Noone is arguing that Dempsey isnt as well. Would Dempsey make us a better passing side ala Pienaar or would he just be adding goals? (no bad thing)

Both in my opinion. If Dempsey can do even half of what he tallied at Fulham last season he would repay half his transfer fee or more in his first year.

 

[james2805]

Cahill may have been poor last season but he's still a hero

on yer bike lad

On my bike?

I put hero in inverted marks because the term is fan specific, different players are hero's to different people. He has been poor for at least 2 by the way, even if he fooled you by the team catering to his needs for the begging of 2010/2011.

 

[Del]

If we waste a our transfer budget on this one season wonder I will cry

 

[bluebottle]

Both in my opinion. If Dempsey can do even half of what he tallied at Fulham last season he would repay half his transfer fee or more in his first year.

Im not so sure on that front. I think with the money we have we can buy a midfield playmaker which would be my preference.

 

[Joao Moutinho]

If we waste a our transfer budget on this one season wonder I will cry

this on toast, with cheese

 

[james2805]

Ridiculous to neg rep me Artetafan just because I used inverted marks when saying hero.

Like I just said, not everyone is a hero to everyone else.

So because I dont count Cahill as one of my heroes it makes my opinion invalid and worth neg repping?

I thought this website was better than that.

He was an iconic figure to me when he played in his prime, but he was not a hero of mine.

 

[Allezfan]

Ridiculous to neg rep me Artetafan just because I used inverted marks when saying hero.

Like I just said, not everyone is a hero to everyone else.

So because I dont count Cahill as one of my heroes it makes my opinion invalid and worth neg repping?

I thought this website was better than that.

He was an iconic figure to me when he played in his prime, but he was not a hero of mine.

I'm not this website. I speak, and rep, only for myself.

 

[james2805]

Im not so sure on that front. I think with the money we have we can buy a midfield playmaker.

Midfield playmaker does not necessarily have to play behind the striker, can't we have both mate? 2 strikers (one behind main) and a playmaker.

 

[Joao Moutinho]

On my bike?

I put hero in inverted marks because the term is fan specific, different players are hero's to different people. He has been poor for at least 2 by the way, even if he fooled you by the team catering to his needs for the begging of 2010/2011.

Most Evertonians consider him a hero mate, he wasnt as bad in 10/11

 

[james2805]

I'm not this website. I speak, and rep, only for myself.

Fair play, still makes you a tit.

 

[ToffeeMark]

I miss cahill now. Rodwell's gone, Cahill's gone. Some woman's singing a sad song at the olympics, I'm crying here

 

[Sharpys top lip]

I miss cahill now. Rodwell's gone, Cahill's gone. So woman's singing a sad song at the olympics, I'm crying here

Tears like..