Basil Fawlty
Player Valuation: £35m
Peter Beardsley. Knew he was a good player but after having been over there for years I just knew he'd be turd for us. Turned out to be one of my favourite players from the early '90's. Class act.

A couple for the older one's, remember when we signed Mickey Walsh from Blackpool after he won the goal of the season, turned out to be utter gash. the there was a player named Dave Clement (think that's how it's spelt) I thought who the [Poor language removed] is this fella, he turned out to be a great signing for us.
Dave Clements was first one I had to google. does sound like a cracking player but never heard anyone chat about him before.
Legs like tree trunks Dave Clements was past his best , but a class act served us well great passer of the ball also we had Colin Todd from Derby who did not do as well as Clements!
I remember when we signed Van Den Hauwe and I thought he was a yard dog and replacing one of my first heroes John Bailey, a real footballer. can't argue he was a yard dog any more and did score the winner against Norwich. still would have loved to have seen John Bailey as a regular in the 84/5 team though
if we talking about getting it wrong with players at other clubs I was insistent few years back that Bale was a one dimensional flash in the panDarron Gibson. Christian Benteke. Probably Dale Jennings. About fifty others too.
Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.