2018/19 Phil Jagielka

[bicycleheader]

I understand the rules of football very well thank you. It is not a matter of understanding the rules, it is a matter of interpretation of them.

But you said the below.....i was just pointing out it was wrong

"nor endangering an opponent since he mostly got the ball"

You can get 100% of the ball and still be sent off for endangering an opponent.[/QUOTE]

 

[Kantareller]

A touch like that is a red card alone. If it was a Wolves' player you'd be screaming for a red anyway.

 

[LouReedwalkonthewildside]

Reckless my arsehole, its a perfectly executed tackle.

Put the alcohol down Goat.

Never a red for denying a goal scoring opportunity though, so they got it wrong.

 

[trueblue84]

I watched the game and I guenuelly thought it was a yellow, when the ref showed him the red card I was astounded it was never a red.

Really? A yellow? It was a good challenge.

 

[Carl O'Ancelotti]

But you said the below.....i was just pointing out it was wrong

"nor endangering an opponent since he mostly got the ball"

You can get 100% of the ball and still be sent off for endangering an opponent.

[/QUOTE]
Its not wrong.

 

[Caolam]

I was surprised by the red card, I thought he played the ball. He certainly was committed but I don't think he was out of control.

 

[trueblue84]

Was it Phil Neville who did that challenge on Ronaldo years ago? The whole of Goodison errupted. It was a full blooded but fair challenge.

Those days are well and truly gone if anyone thinks that was a foul.

 

[Toffee in Jandals]

Debate about red cards aside, it's really disappointing for Jags if that's his last act in an Everton shirt. Decent fella who has been a good servant of the club.

 

[trueblue84]

Debate about red cards aside, it's really disappointing for Jags if that's his last act in an Everton shirt. Decent fella who has been a good servant of the club.

It won't be. He will get plenty of chances this season.

 

[billyblue80]

I still think it was a yellow but he shouldn't have been in that position to start with. I don't think he's up to this level regularly anymore. Maybe for the odd game but he doesn't have that half a yard and makes errors he didn't used to.

 

[LouReedwalkonthewildside]

But you said the below.....i was just pointing out it was wrong

"nor endangering an opponent since he mostly got the ball"

You can get 100% of the ball and still be sent off for endangering an opponent.

[/QUOTE]

The same with a high foot, you could get 100% of the ball, and it can still be considered as serious foul play.

 

[Badge1878]

His right foot is like a trigger though isn’t it. Was it a red ....on my one look at at, a no all day long.

Nice guy, role model, managers LIkw him and had a career beyond his expectations....but tonight. Let’s say it as it was. He lost control of the ball outdide our eighteen yard box through complacency when we were one up. He is our captain not some kid making his debut.

Sentiment aside, how he has been allowed to stay a part of our squad is beyond me. It’s beyond his ability. We’ve seen enough - nice guy and all that - but not good enough.

 

[stretford blue]

He won the ball. Was a joke of decision and never a red card. Simple as that. Even the contact after that wasn’t as bad as people are making. He wasn’t even high. It’s a contact sport ffs. Then you have bloody Peter Walton who was a garbage ref saying it was a red just because he was stretching for it. What a joke!

Walton even said later on the it didn't matter if jags touched the ball first i give up

 

[bicycleheader]

I don't agree. I've saw it countless times and I think he made a good firm challenge. He played all of the ball before the man. If you're correct that it's a red card then I don't like the way the game is going. Not one Wolves player expected a red card. Players aren't stupid.

Well i dont think that kind of decision is black and white....so I can only say I can understand why the ref made that decision if it genuinely was for dangerous play

 

[Goat]

Put the alcohol down Goat.

Never a red for denying a goal scoring opportunity though, so they got it wrong.

Mate I dont even drink, im not somebody who takes offence when der meeja diss us and I honestly thought Niasse getting done for diving last season was the right thing. But that today was a joke, it honestly wasnt a foul for me, not even close, to see a red card angers me a LOT.