Muhamed Besic

[Hungariansupport]

The major difference between the two is that Besic looks to impose himself on a game. This means that he often looks like he offers more. The problem is that most of us don't know enough about football to know whether that's because he's better or if it's just a stylistic difference.

I think it's mainly the style. Football is something You watch because You want to see beautiful things. Something good for Your eyes. A hard working DM is very important for the team but a hard working DM who can do dribbles/tackles/hard passes has more artistic value. And even when result is the most important thing You'll love the latter most - even if You're not aware of that. Also it's more risky than just work on the pitch but everything comes with a price...

 

[chicoazul]

In response to your other point, the principle remains that it is possible to look at players attributes and determine whether he is a better player than another. if you followed you're own criteria for judging a player then you would need to say that you need to see Besic play more in order to determine who is the better player because at the moment you don't have enough evidence to make a judgement. Basically if you prefer McCarthy that's fine but don't pretend this is based on evidence. Besic dominated the midfield in games against Tottenham and City. McCarthy typically hides in his shell against quality opposition and just crabs it side ways and backwards.

Your posts are riddled with bias towards Besic.

It's only natural after going "all in" on his supposed talent from an early stage with Everton that you se McCarthy as his competitor and therefore seek to, foolishly, devalue his proven worth to the team.

That's OK though as you're polite and as a result I will not crush you.

 

[AJC5]

Your posts are riddled with bias towards Besic.

It's only natural after going "all in" on his supposed talent from an early stage with Everton that you se McCarthy as his competitor and therefore seek to, foolishly, devalue his proven worth to the team.

That's OK though as you're polite and as a result I will not crush you.

Thank you kind sir. McCarthy is valuable to the team but Besic has much more potential and his presents in the team has coincided with very good performances against good teams.

 

[chicoazul]

Thank you kind sir. McCarthy is valuable to the team but Besic has much more potential and his presents in the team has coincided with very good performances against good teams.

I agree but I have to pretend otherwise to make @MoutsGoat a very angry fat man.

 

[Woolly Blue]

lol

trying to be amusing and right wing in your posting sentiment - like a GOT version of Roy Chubby Brown

Great posts keno, seeing as you're totally new to the forum and haven't posted before, do you have a view, or MULTIple views on Mirrrallas starting ?

Sigh.
Both of you. Quit this sort of post.

FYI - A smart arse reply will be interpreted as ignoring the message I'm delivering

 

[Chang Elephant]

Sigh.
Both of you. Quit this sort of post.

FYI - A smart arse reply will be interpreted as ignoring the message I'm delivering

Thank you WB

 

[Kev The Rat]

Looking a much better player now than he was but frankly we have far greater issues to resolve

 

[Walken]

Looking a much better player now than he was but frankly we have far greater issues to resolve

glad you have admitted you were wrong, fair play

 

[Kev The Rat]

glad you have admitted you were wrong, fair play

I don't admit I was wrong. At the time he was not good enough IMO. Raised his game/developed as a player fair play to him.

 

[admirschleck]

I don't admit I was wrong.

LOL

 

[chicoazul]

Looking a much better player now than he was but frankly we have far greater issues to resolve

Kev as always I stand shoulder to shoulder with you in your quest.

 

[Walken]

I don't admit I was wrong. At the time he was not good enough IMO. Raised his game/developed as a player fair play to him.

he must have basically changed into an entirely different entity then given the tripe you were writing about, the safer bet (you know a fair bit about safe betting) would be to say as usual Kevin, you were wrong

 

[Woolly Blue]

Thank you WB

That's probably the most you could get away with as a sarcy answer !
Good call. You might want to leave it there though ?

 

[Walken]

That's probably the most you could get away with as a sarcy answer !
Good call. You might want to leave it there though ?

chill out eastwood

 

[Kev The Rat]

Kev as always I stand shoulder to shoulder with you in your quest.

So long as I get a few people swearing into their monitors/mobile devices its mission accomplished.