I think Portugal is in a similar situation to a lot of leagues with quality players. Holland is a step up from Argentina in many respects and one them is obviously money. I wouldn't say PSV or Feyenoord are bigger clubs than Boca Juniors or River Plate but it's a bigger stage with European football on offer as a shop window. Most (99% I'd say) players would like to play for one of the top teams in one of the top leagues. The Mathew LeTissiers of this world are few and far between. At the present time the 3 most attractive clubs in the world for players, taking into consideration history, fanbase, current success and financial punch are Manure, Real Madrid and Milan AC. If one of them come calling it's difficult to say no. So while playing 6-10 CL games will get you seen by one of those, Playing 38-50 games in the same league as them is better. Obviously an Everton, Portsmouth, Sampdoria or Villareal is a better stepping stone for a talented young lad form Ajax, Sporting Lisbon or Dukla Prague than joining a Stoke, Cagliari or Real Murcia.
Ten teams from six different countries all in one sentence. Beat that
Looking at the portuguese national team, there a ratio of players playing abroad in big clubs hard to beat in Europe.
If you look at the first eleven, 3 defenders will play for chelsea and 1 for real madrid. in the midfield the only one playing abroad plays for barça and will play for chelsea. Upfront, 1 for Man U and 1 for Atletico Madrid. The goalkeeper plays for Betis. So, 8 players play abroad and only 2 aren't playing for CL prime prize challengers.
This means that big players in Portugal leave for big clubs. The portuguese championship is well known, and the national team is followed throughout the world. There is no need to leave on loan to a club that will serve as a winder for big clubs to watch the player.
Only common class players will do that. Manny at the time was well regarded and followed by big clubs. Followed meant that people was expecting him to mature. Leaving for a smaller club, didn't do him any good.
He's casting himself as a player who doesn't settle anywhere. He's been with for 2 incomplete seasons on loan, and that's hardly some sort of stability.
Do you remember Hugo Viana? At that time he was considered Europe's hottest property. He chose Newcastle for the money instead of Juventus. From that point on, he played out of position, then was loaned back to Sporting, sold to Valencia and loaned to Osasuna. He lost a lot of his progression.
I'm afraid that will happen to Manny. If we want him, we should sign him permanently. If not, let him go. No more loans.