I think Lukaku is great and want him to sign primarily because of that. It's insanely hard to find a consistent goal scorer. If you look over the goal scoring charts you can count the number of players who appear near the top each year on one hand. He could be there (he almost is for the last two years depending on where you cut off the charts).
But regardless of all that ... I want us to get him because it would truly feel different for Everton. It would signal intent and that things really are different now. I know we all loved our style of play this year and beating top teams ... but ultimately you could argue: we've finished fifth before.
Moyes managed it (and better) and he's literally the worst manager who has ever existed right?
If RM can pull this signing off, convince Lukaku to sign and convince BK to pay ... then things are *really* changing.