I can see what you're saying, certainly does have a record of scoring against us.
All I can say is for me his legs have gone, don't think his heart is really in it anymore and he's not the type of personality you look to bring into the club. Especially someone his age you would be expecting to set standards as a professional and I dont think he's that guy.
He can finish, give him a chance in the box and he'll take it, but is that really how we play? He would basically need to just hang around the box, maybe the only way it would be possible for an Everton striker to be more isolated than they already have been this season.
Can understand your points also mate.
All i can think of is them scuffed chances by Barry and Beto in the box, or the balls we have no one on the ned of that i think Wilson buries (if fit). Id stress over a three year deal, but wouldnt loose much sleep on a short term incentive based contract.