2025/26 James Tarkowski

Yup, but I’d rather wait until he shows some evidence of decline, rather than just point to his age or assume his replacement will be an improvement.

He’s still topping the stats and getting in PL teams of the week.
At least we have seen his replacement, playing in his correct position - he was fine.

Tarkowski’s lack of pace is worrying, as he gets older, it will decline. I’d rather remember him for his good times than wait until he becomes our VVD.
 
I just prefer us to sign top half defenders rather than relegation battle specialists. The fact he's a thug also makes me not like him.
We needed a 'thug' for many years.
We let ourselves get bullied by too many teams for too long.
It was horrible to always have to admit that the biggest thug playing in red, who was also their best player, was more up for derby games than our soft bunch. A Tarkowski wouldn't have been scared to kick him off the park.

You need a nasty so and so. To get in the ref's ear and cross the line sometimes. We have one that doesn't get send off, what is not to like?
Simpletons like Fernandez at United will run the game by talking a ref's ear off if you don't go right through on of their players from time to time to show them we are not who we used to anymore.
 
It shows that Refs don’t think he’s an uncontrolled thug, even if you are desperate to make him out as one.
He clearly is. That fact he’s got away with doesn’t disprove it. A murder who doesn’t get caught is still a murderer. You don’t mind a bit of thuggery on the pitch, I get it, I prefer players who don’t consistently try to hurt the opposition.
 

Similar Threads

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top