James McCarthy

AsiaAsia82 · April 17, 2019

Don’t play him before the end of the season, we need to sell him when he’s still fit to play

RichardP · April 17, 2019

mkrudden said:
Why has 7th already gone?
And why isn't Siggy in your line up.?.?

Seventh has already gone because of our difficult run in compared, primarily, with Wolves.

I like Siggy but he has been very hit and miss. Gets the headlines when he scores but I feel my 4-3-3 with Siggy on the bench makes us stronger.

toffeejack · April 17, 2019

RichardP said:
Seventh has already gone because of our difficult run in compared, primarily, with Wolves.

I like Siggy but he has been very hit and miss. Gets the headlines when he scores but I feel my 4-3-3 with Siggy on the bench makes us stronger.

Wolves have a poor record against bad teams though

Real_madras · April 17, 2019

sageyefc said:
Wage thief, get rid

To be fair on him, he wanted to go out on loan in January. Silva wouldn't let him. Not his fault he doesn't get picked.

ijjysmith · April 17, 2019

Real_madras said:
To be fair on him, he wanted to go out on loan in January. Silva wouldn't let him. Not his fault he doesn't get picked.

If he was a better footballer he’d get picked.

Tree13 · April 17, 2019

LostLegend said:
I can see why you’d make that comparison given the similarity of the injury.

But Coleman is not usually an injury prone player. McCarthy on the other hand:

Over 700 days out injured.

105 games missed.

Yet people want to keep him.

Tel001 · April 18, 2019

toffeejack said:
Wolves have a poor record against bad teams though

They took 4 points off us

degsy · April 18, 2019

ijjysmith said:
If he was a better footballer he’d get picked.

Pretty much this. If fit Schneiderlin will start Vs United

McBain · April 18, 2019

We should play him but only in bubblewrap.

ilikecheese · April 18, 2019

Hard to believe it's been five years since his first season.

CRIMHEAD · April 18, 2019

ijjysmith said:
If he was a better footballer he’d get picked.

That's kind of my point. Although Silva hasn't been perfect in his evaluation of his own players. Think about how long it took for him to sit Walcott down.

irishgoose · April 18, 2019

degsy said:
Pretty much this. If fit Schneiderlin will start Vs United

Still a fraud. I hope he does not start

fandjango · April 18, 2019

ilikecheese said:
Hard to believe it's been five years since his first season.

Seems like 10

Canuck Darryl · April 18, 2019

It seems that every player that doesn’t fit our plans going forward, is loaned out with the hope that the other club will eventually purchase the player at some point.

Just where McCarthy fits in is a bit of a mystery to me. Silva says he’s fit and training well, but won’t play him, even with the under23’s, and doesn’t put him out on loan even though he seems to be access baggage.

He was a decent player before the broken leg. If he’s back to his old form, he could be useful. If not, why is he still here?

McBain · April 18, 2019

Canuck Darryl said:
It seems that every player that doesn’t fit our plans going forward, is loaned out with the hope that the other club will eventually purchase the player at some point.

Just where McCarthy fits in is a bit of a mystery to me. Silva says he’s fit and training well, but won’t play him, even with the under23’s, and doesn’t put him out on loan even though he seems to be access baggage.

He was a decent player before the broken leg. If he’s back to his old form, he could be useful. If not, why is he still here?

For the Bantz.