Current Affairs Israel is an apartheid state

[WA Toffee]

Your recent posts do not read like that, but fine.

To be fair, your recent posts are the exact type I was parodying. The type that go - if you do not agree with me 100%, then you must support the exact opposite view. No nuance allowed. No context permitted. Just focus on polar opposites so I can attack you. It is the style of discussion I am commenting on, not the content.

As I said, it is a lazy style of conversation, and really serves just to shut down discussion rather than build it.

Oh, and just to be clear (yet again) - I do not in any way support or condone what Israel is doing in Palestine.

 

[Bluerover]

Israel detains 240 Palestinians after Gaza hospital raid

Israeli forces have detained more than 240 Palestinians including dozens of medical staff and the director of a north Gaza hospital they raided yesterday, according to the Health Ministry in Gaza and Israel's military.

www.rte.ie

Charming

 

[d34noj]

No one has ever said that in this thread you pathetic little bell. No one. Difference is, A. October 7th did not happen in a vacuum, and B. Israel is conducting a genocide in Gaza. If you want to cheer the murder of innocent women, children, journalists and aid workers go ahead, but say it with your chest and don’t try and moralise your support for a genocide.

I’m so done with people like you, and Cork, and d34 who just argue in awful faith, when you are blatantly just racists who love seeing brown children and women murdered.

So the terror attacks on October 7th were warranted.

I see.

 

[d34noj]

Thing is in all reality you're just an Israeli apologist, perspective my arse. You're here to justify a genocide.

Dry your tears mate.

Tell you what, what do YOU want me to say, and I'll say that. Can't go against the grain and say Hamas are naughty boys can we.

 

[d34noj]

Israel detains 240 Palestinians after Gaza hospital raid

Israeli forces have detained more than 240 Palestinians including dozens of medical staff and the director of a north Gaza hospital they raided yesterday, according to the Health Ministry in Gaza and Israel's military.

www.rte.ie

Charming

Israel shuts down Hamas control centre and arrests suspected militants. Existing patients are moved to another hospital.

Don't see the issue?

 

[d34noj]

To be fair, your recent posts are the exact type I was parodying. The type that go - if you do not agree with me 100%, then you must support the exact opposite view. No nuance allowed. No context permitted. Just focus on polar opposites so I can attack you. It is the style of discussion I am commenting on, not the content.

As I said, it is a lazy style of conversation, and really serves just to shut down discussion rather than build it.

Oh, and just to be clear (yet again) - I do not in any way support or condone what Israel is doing in Palestine.

Exactly this. Like I've said in various threads, echo chamber.

Narrow minded bigotry.

 

[Bluerover]

Israel shuts down Hamas control centre and arrests suspected militants. Existing patients are moved to another hospital.

Don't see the issue?

The World Health Organization is obviously a Hamas supporter.

One of Gaza's last functioning hospitals 'now empty' after Israeli attack

Around 60 health workers and 25 patients in critical condition reportedly remain in Kamal Adwan Hospital.

www.thejournal.ie

 

[Wizard]

Israel shuts down Hamas control centre and arrests suspected militants. Existing patients are moved to another hospital.

Don't see the issue?

At the very least this seems like a bit of an issue

"The remaining 15 critical patients, 50 caregivers and 20 health workers were yesterday transferred to Indonesian Hospital, which it described as "destroyed and non-functional"."

 

[d34noj]

The World Health Organization is obviously a Hamas supporter.

One of Gaza's last functioning hospitals 'now empty' after Israeli attack

Around 60 health workers and 25 patients in critical condition reportedly remain in Kamal Adwan Hospital.

www.thejournal.ie

I'm aware it's a hospital and it's been shut down mate. I'm not questioning that, I'm saying if the intelligence is correct and it is a Hamas control centre, with Hamas terrorists inside - then Israel are correct in shutting it down.

The WHO really ought to be blaming Hamas for using that building (if it is the case)

 

[d34noj]

At the very least this seems like a bit of an issue

"The remaining 15 critical patients, 50 caregivers and 20 health workers were yesterday transferred to Indonesian Hospital, which it described as "destroyed and non-functional"."

Agreed, however does it say it was destroyed and non-functional due to Israel or because of Hamas using it as a military stronghold?

 

[Wizard]

I'm aware it's a hospital and it's been shut down mate. I'm not questioning that, I'm saying if the intelligence is correct and it is a Hamas control centre, with Hamas terrorists inside - then Israel are correct in shutting it down.

The WHO really ought to be blaming Hamas for using that building (if it is the case)

I mean your first post on the story just blindly accepted Israel's version of events and said you can't see the issue. Now you've thrown in a couple of ifs so progress I guess

 

[Bluerover]

I'm aware it's a hospital and it's been shut down mate. I'm not questioning that, I'm saying if the intelligence is correct and it is a Hamas control centre, with Hamas terrorists inside - then Israel are correct in shutting it down.

The WHO really ought to be blaming Hamas for using that building (if it is the case)

I think you are a reasonable person, and your contributions are polite.

However critically ill patients are not running a Hamas Control Centre.

 

[d34noj]

I think you are a reasonable person, and your contributions are polite.

However critically ill patients are not running a Hamas Control Centre.

I'm aware they're not mate, however I - nor you are positive it wasn't being used by Hamas.

I mean your first post on the story just blindly accepted Israel's version of events and said you can't see the issue. Now you've thrown in a couple of ifs so progress I guess

I didn't accept it, I said if it's being used as a military Base by Hamas I'm fine with it being emptied and suspects arrested.

 

[Wizard]

I'm aware they're not mate, however I - nor you are positive it wasn't being used by Hamas.



I didn't accept it, I said if it's being used as a military Base by Hamas I'm fine with it being emptied and suspects arrested.

No if in here...

"Israel shuts down Hamas control centre and arrests suspected militants. Existing patients are moved to another hospital.

Don't see the issue?"

 

[d34noj]

No if in here...

"Israel shuts down Hamas control centre and arrests suspected militants. Existing patients are moved to another hospital.

Don't see the issue?"

It was meant to read 'if this is the case'.

I, nor you, or even the WHO know whether it was the case. I'm saying if it is, then it's warranted.