In hindsight who would you have chosen

If you could go back in time who would you have chosen as you manager in November?


  • Total voters
    275
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
People aren't under the illusion that Dyche plays entertaining football right?
It's taken FIVE years for that squeaky dog-chewtoy voiced Max and Paddy-a-like to become flavour of the month.

No indication that he'd get results elsewhere in any sort of useful timeframe.

Sam was (and remains) the only credible option until he evolves the squad to the point a proper manager would turn their back on the CL where they are, to come and improve us.
 
I like his demeanour and no nonsense talk. Think given a chance to sign the obvious flaws in our squad then judge him from then on. I think he gets Everton and our ambition and need to play attractive but effective football
 
I think everyone, including Allerdyce, knows that he will be replaced in the summer. He will be paid handsomely and will redeem his reputation and get a gig managing Wales or something.

He is not an Everton manager, despite all this guff about sorting out the defence and an unbeaten run. Christ it's as if we are West Brom or something. The reasons for players being shithouses for the first 16 games goes beyond the managers door imho.

This club is in danger of losing its identify in the next 3-4 years if we are not careful. I'm a believer in Moshiri, although whether Usmanov is involved remains adrift of my understanding.

In the interim I'm not sure it matters who is manager but we've absolutely got to get it right with the next manager.
What identity? For the past thirty years we have been a mid to lower premier league team, often playing 'dogs-of-war' style football. Literally nobody outside of Everton identifies us as an attractive team that should be challenging for honours.
 
Allardyce gets teams organised.

So do a lot of other managers.

There is a reason Allardyce hasn't progressed in his career. It is because he can't spot players, doesn't improve them and the football he plays is dire.
 
I think everyone, including Allerdyce, knows that he will be replaced in the summer. He will be paid handsomely and will redeem his reputation and get a gig managing Wales or something.

He is not an Everton manager, despite all this guff about sorting out the defence and an unbeaten run. Christ it's as if we are West Brom or something. The reasons for players being shithouses for the first 16 games goes beyond the managers door imho.

This club is in danger of losing its identify in the next 3-4 years if we are not careful. I'm a believer in Moshiri, although whether Usmanov is involved remains adrift of my understanding.

In the interim I'm not sure it matters who is manager but we've absolutely got to get it right with the next manager.



He's steadied the ship and removed the spectre of relegation. Make no mistake, and I know you don't, we were sinking like a brick before he came in, written off by all and sundry.

I don't know about identity, I think it's confused with history and when it comes to chatting about success, our history is all we have to talk about. This isn't the school of science anymore and we aren't the merseyside millionaires of days gone by.

Short, medium and long them success each require different strategies.
For the short term we needed to be steadied. BFS is performing a very necessary purpose at the moment.

Who is an Everton manager?
The last two clearly didn't work out.
Moyes did well and had us at the right end of the table but we had enough of him.
Unless someone can come in and get us in the Champions league and winning a cup or two they won't be good enough.
The next appointment is absolutely crucial but it will be a risk. For the time being I'm happy enough that we are up the table and hard to beat. Let's see what the window brings.
 
Ratcliffe today in the Echo on Silva: "He's been found out at Watford".

They're top half and having their best season for years.

Then he touts Eddie Howe for the Everton job...currently managing Bournemouth to the relegation zone.

FFS, this feller is clueless.
 
Ratcliffe today in the Echo on Silva: "He's been found out at Watford".

They're top half and having their best season for years.

Then he touts Eddie Howe for the Everton job...currently managing Bournemouth to the relegation zone.

FFS, this feller is clueless.
Is he a club mouthpiece now?

If so it probably shows we have moved on from Silva and the board are 100% Big Sam.
 
Ratcliffe today in the Echo on Silva: "He's been found out at Watford".

They're top half and having their best season for years.

Then he touts Eddie Howe for the Everton job...currently managing Bournemouth to the relegation zone.

FFS, this feller is clueless.

No doubt about that Dave. For me there are still problems ahead, we are not out of danger yet by any means, have to make do with the manager we have for now. Signing a couple of players in January is not magic wand time neither is letting some go but needs to be done. our current manager needs to appraise the playing staff and sort out the dross.

As for that list, do not want any of those failures, we must stick it out to the end of the season and then see how we stand.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar Threads

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top