Howard v Binman

[mouser]

If you were to pick an all time Everton team big nev or tim remember nev had the back pass wich does make it easier.Dont get me wrong im not knocking big Nev i love him but Tim is class in my opinion all modern goalies make big blunders.Anyway am i having a laugh even thinking about it.

 

[Barlows Boots]

No camparison

 

[heatmeiser]

Nev is one of the greatest keepers of all time.

With all respect to him, Tim isn't.

It isn't even close to be fair.

 

[Summerskin]

Howard is quality through and through.

But Big Nev was the best of all time, so it's a no brainer really.

 

[chrissyjack]

Big Nev , every time

 

[Basil Fawlty]

No contest. Nev is the only player we've had in my lifetime who was the best in THE WORLD in his position. Tim is a good keeper but is prone to mistakes.

 

[alan ball]

Howard is a quality keeper and grateful for him but Southall i would imagine would be Everton's greatest goalie ever

 

[Axlswhk]

Tim is not even as good as Nigel Martyn, and Nev is way better than Martyn.

 

[chrissyjack]

You might as well try to compare Graeme Sharp to Bernie " The Bolt" Wright

 

[Gerard_Francis]

No contest. Nev is the only player we've had in my lifetime who was the best in THE WORLD in his position. Tim is a good keeper but is prone to mistakes.

Can’t argue with this

 

[edge]

nev every time, not a fan of howards at all, played great on saturday but still to many daft mistakes ,cant command his area dithers when coming out and pushes the ball out when making saves, not really in the same league as nev or martyn, i would have him with the likes of woods or hodge not bad but deffo not great

 

[zed]

If you were to pick an all time Everton team big nev or tim remember nev had the back pass wich does make it easier.Dont get me wrong im not knocking big Nev i love him but Tim is class in my opinion all modern goalies make big blunders.Anyway am i having a laugh even thinking about it.

you are having a laugh with your thinking but it just shows how high you regard howard to even compare him to nev. i got no worries having howard in goal and i like the fella as well but big nev was in a class of his own

 

[ijjysmith]

Is this thread real?

 

[Reidy's Bottle Of Grecian]

Big Nev without doubt, I remember against Rotherham in the league cup and some fella hits one from the edge of the box, it left his foot and their end went up, Nev casually strolled across his line, grabbed it with 1 hand and put it on his hip.


He may have scored the winning penalty that night ?

 

[little curly alan ball]

If you were to pick an all time Everton team big nev or tim remember nev had the back pass wich does make it easier.Dont get me wrong im not knocking big Nev i love him but Tim is class in my opinion all modern goalies make big blunders.Anyway am i having a laugh even thinking about it.

Stop this NOW , young Sir .

YOU KNOW FUKN BETTER !!!

Most on here know I'm not a lover of Howard - if ANYONE calls him T-HOW , I will go POSTAL , incidentally ,... Pointless denying it . An' he DID have a blinder , Sat' . Agreed .

However , I see you with B'burn , and raise you Aston Vila , where he didn't even bother to lift his arms . Poss' wouldn't have saved it anyway , but we'll never know now , will we ???

Sir Nev' , on the other hand , was TRUE genius , and was better than most around now even on his WORST day .

No , no , and THRICE NO !!!