Guardiola on Arteta

Status
Not open for further replies.
In the City documentary you see how passionate and vocal Pep is, he is constantly telling players what he wants from them and trying to motivate them. Arteta seems quiet in comparison so while he may well have picked up a lot tactically from Pep he might not have the force of personality required to put it in to practice. When Pep was sent off in the Champs league quarter final and Arteta was on the touchline he looked lost to me.. Would be a huge gamble
 
Eggs said:
....I wondered if Silva had been sacked for a minute.

I always judge a new manager by his dealings in the transfer market, but I suppose that element becomes much less of an issue when you have a DoF.

It makes the appointment of a ‘coach’ much less risky. Arteta has been working with the best, so he must be an attractive proposition. Saying that, he was hammered by many of our fans after he left, so even if we were in the market for a new Manager, he might not want to come to us.
Click to expand...

I think you’d all welcome me at the helm if it meant the axe was to fall, but we all know this won’t happen any time soon as Moshiri cannot be seen to lose face; at least till the season’s end.
 
Jay said:
"He decided to stay - thanks - but everyone decides what he'll do in the future. Sooner or later it’s going to happen. He's a young young manager, he’s 37, 38, so he so young, he has experience already to handle big players and teams."

"We can change something in the team thanks to his vision or what he has seen but I'm pretty sure he was a holding midfielder too and he can read the situation and he was a master of that."

"He's a guy who has this ability to see what happens. When you're off the pitch and on the pitch it's easier, he can do it... we see the football in a really quite close way."

"He's an incredible human being, with incredible values about what it means in the locker room and to be together, and he is already an incredible manager and he'll have incredible success in his future."
Click to expand...
tenor.gif


Perfect example of a word cocktail. Says about nothing clear, but about 1000 words of crap.
 
Lelouch said:
I can see why people want Arteta but it would be a bigger risk than Silva, To chance it on hoping Pep's magic has rubbed off on Arteta is borderline crazy tbh.
Click to expand...

Yeah. not yet. He may not even want Everton he might want Man CIty or Arsenal first, and then of course later Barcelona or Madrid - which one is he gonna go for? In any case, we will be lucky to have him for 3 - 5 years if he thinks we are a good stepping stone to a big job and if he's actually gonna be a good manager
 
Name me one manager who wouldn't be a gamble. Anyone saying we need PL experience is kidding themselves. It means nothing. It's irrelevant. It usually means they're only available because they previously failed.

For once could we please pick the young up and coming manager with potentially a very high ceiling rather than the mundane bog standard known entity whose flaws are already really evident.

Arteta is the exciting choice. If someone is good enough for Man City and Guardiola, then they are good enough for us. That's the reality.
 
I would prefer someone with a proven track record of at least moderate success, but if the club is going to be shopping in the Silva/Allardyce range again, then yeah, may as well give Arteta a go.
 
Lelouch said:
I can see why people want Arteta but it would be a bigger risk than Silva, To chance it on hoping Pep's magic has rubbed off on Arteta is borderline crazy tbh.
Click to expand...

I'm sure pep plugged Arteta into him via usb and uploaded his experience with barca Munich and City and now he's extremely equipped to manage a team like Everton on his first attempt at a job.
 
Jonte said:
I think you’d all welcome me at the helm if it meant the axe was to fall, but we all know this won’t happen any time soon as Moshiri cannot be seen to lose face; at least till the season’s end.
Click to expand...

...I’m not a particular fan of Silva, but I certainly don’t want the axe to fall on him. Continual change doesn’t work and we’ve been on a merry go round for too long. Invariably successful managers go through bad times in the early stages and I hope that’s the case with Silva.

I’m sure Moshiri wants stability whilst the ground development continues, I think we’ll need to be in a crisis (less than 20 points at Christmas) for a sacking to be contemplated. Also, I think Silva’s relationship with Brands would need to break down, and I don’t see signs of that.
 
We are talking about being a big club about wanting to challenge for a top six position and then maybe even better... and we want to do this by appointing somebody who has never ever manager a team.

If we want Arteta as a manager at some future date bring him in as coach now with an older more experienced manager for a couple of seasons.... somebody like Wenger and let's at least see what he can offer without taking the absolute risk of appointing him on his own.
 
ToffeeTim said:
Name me one manager who wouldn't be a gamble. Anyone saying we need PL experience is kidding themselves. It means nothing. It's irrelevant. It usually means they're only available because they previously failed.

For once could we please pick the young up and coming manager with potentially a very high ceiling rather than the mundane bog standard known entity whose flaws are already really evident.

Arteta is the exciting choice. If someone is good enough for Man City and Guardiola, then they are good enough for us. That's the reality.
Click to expand...
It isn't about Premiership experience.... he has no experience at any level.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar Threads

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

→ Log in 🔑 Register
🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top