Current Affairs George Floyd and Minneapolis Unrest

Status
Not open for further replies.
I dont believe that to be true.

If we exchange black for ethnic minority in the UK.

Then look at the vile things which happened to young white girls in the Asian grooming cases and also at other examples in areas where there were more minorities than whites then it doesnt ring true for me.

What about other races living as a minority within those minority groups...
That is such an unrelated situation it is incredible. The Asian grooming gangs are not an example of systemic abuses based on race. They have nothing to do with privilege, white or other. White people have not been oppressed in the UK for years by Asian grooming gangs.

I'll repeat what I said before. Some white people have a harder time than some people of minority races. The vast majority however do not when their societal situations are equivalent. Therefore there is white privilege in the UK (same goes for US and all majority white countries). This is not a racist thing to say against white people, it is merely a statement of fact.
 
Quite simple for me, a lived experience can give more insight than an opinion on someone else's lived experience.
Evidently not that simple to understand my point then, because that doesn't address it at all. As I said, I evidently didn't put it across very well in writing.

To simplify it in this context, in order for a person of colour to know whether their lived experience has been affected by racism, they would need to have an opinion on someone else's lived experience. Without that they couldn't possibly know whether what they experience is specific to their skin colour. A black person saying they've been subject to stop and search is not evidence of racism. Official statistics which show that black people are disproportionately affected by stop and search is evidence of racism. My point was that racism is all too real, but I don't necessarily believe that disagreeing with a person of colour over whether something is racist makes you 'part of the problem' or whatever.

It appears that I mistakenly thought @mill was going down the road of - as an example - 'if a wool says it's offensive to be called a wool then it's offensive and that's that'. I come across that type of argument a lot in my line of work and it annoys me, so I was compelled to post. He wasn't though, so I needn't have bothered.
 
Evidently not that simple to understand my point then, because that doesn't address it at all. As I said, I evidently didn't put it across very well in writing.

To simplify it in this context, in order for a person of colour to know whether their lived experience has been affected by racism, they would need to have an opinion on someone else's lived experience. Without that they couldn't possibly know whether what they experience is specific to their skin colour. A black person saying they've been subject to stop and search is not evidence of racism. Official statistics which show that black people are disproportionately affected by stop and search is evidence of racism. My point was that racism is all too real, but I don't necessarily believe that disagreeing with a person of colour over whether something is racist makes you 'part of the problem' or whatever.

It appears that I mistakenly thought @mill was going down the road of - as an example - 'if a wool says it's offensive to be called a wool then it's offensive and that's that'. I come across that type of argument a lot in my line of work and it annoys me, so I was compelled to post. He wasn't though, so I needn't have bothered.
Ah. No I wasn’t saying that at all mate!
 
Us Secretary of Defense opposes any use of the Insurrection Act or the deployment of the military against protesters.

He also says he didn't know they were participating in a photo-op outside the Church, or that protesters would be violently dispersed.

 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top