Felli over Baines?

[Chang Elephant]

If I wielded power, all threads talking about choices of who we should sell (other than wank players like Neville etc) would be obliterated.

Kenwright will be bashing his bishop reading this.

 

[justmeinit]

I'd sell fellaini over baines every time, Baines has never once talked about moving he has stayed loyal is a blue and is best left back in world.

 

[alpha1]

Prefer to keep both but if push came to shove I would sell Fellaini.
Baines is possibly the only "world class" player we have (would even get in the Barca side!)
That's not to say Fellaini isn't any good but I do believe he is more replaceable.

 

[Aidey9]

I don't want to sell either of them but if there was a choice I think I'd rather sell Baines. Get good money for him and we have Oviedo here now. Just think we'd miss the big man more. What does everyone think?

I think Bainesy would be alot harder to replace!. He's so consistant, never really as a bad game, never really injured or out through suspension and is a great source of creativity.

As for Felli, he's awesome on his day but he's not consistant with it IMO. And like a few times this season when the game hasnt been going his way, he gets petulant and starts kicking out (WBA) or putting his nut in (Stoke).

I think Felli would be easier to replace. Good FB's are hard to find and we have one of the best!. Good midfielders with potential to be great are all over the continent, IF you have the money.

 

[Aidey9]

Fellaini is being played out of position, he should be laying deep with Gibson with either Osman or Barkley ahead of them.

I think thats what alot of Evertonians would like to see from time to time, Felli deeper and someone else, someone different in behind Jelavic, have a different variation to our game but Moyesy wont do it.

Sometimes i also think we'd be more solid at the back with Felli deeper and taking some of the pressure off of our defence with his height and presence.

 

[bignev23]

For me it would definately be Fellaini. Baines is consistently excellent and i think we`d get a bigger fee for fellaini and replace him easier. Don`t think either will go in january but we all know fellaini is sort off looking for a move so thats another reason i`d keep baines.

 

[electricblue]

Hope Fellaini doesn't see this thread.

*waves goodbye

 

[Brennan]

I hate stupid comments like 'We've won 2 in a row since Fellaini went out of the team'.

Both games have also seen Phil Neville return, does that mean he should start every game as well ?

 

[Stend]

I hate stupid comments like 'We've won 2 in a row since Fellaini went out of the team'.

Both games have also seen Phil Neville return, does that mean he should start every game as well ?

Do you agree that Fellaini being played upfront has led to alot of draws?

Deeper role may benefit our attacking players. Im not sure whats been the problem but more draws wont get us champions league.

 

[Blue Tit]

We all know Fellaini will be off at some point most probably within the next two transfer windows so if you had to choose between selling him or Baines it's bye bye Maro. Get good price for him too as others have said.

Obviously we'd all rather keep both like

 

[Brennan]

Do you agree that Fellaini being played upfront has led to alot of draws?

Deeper role may benefit our attacking players. Im not sure whats been the problem but more draws wont get us champions league.

Seeing as Fellaini is our top scorer, no, i don't think him being played up front has lead to a lot of draws. Without him a lot of those draws would be losses.

 

[Famous Grouse]

I'd deffo be keeping Baines of the two. Read the other day that he has created 65 chances so far this season for us, Messi and Ronaldo have only created 51. Not suggesting he is better than either of them, but we couldn't replace his quality. As boss as Fellaini is, he is the more expendable of the two.

 

[Del]

Seeing as Fellaini is our top scorer, no, i don't think him being played up front has lead to a lot of draws. Without him a lot of those draws would be losses.

“Never argue with stupid people, they will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience"

 

[Woolly Blue]

I don't want to sell either of them but if there was a choice I think I'd rather sell Baines. Get good money for him and we have Oviedo here now. Just think we'd miss the big man more. What does everyone think?

I'd keep Baines, every day. He's just total class. Best player in a blue shirt for absolute beards.

 

[Blue 1]

Felli over Baines?

Baines over Felli more like.

Better player in his position and more important to us.