Current Affairs EU In or Out

In or Out

  • In

    Votes: 688 67.9%
  • Out

    Votes: 325 32.1%

  • Total voters
    1,013
Status
Not open for further replies.
... and that would be absurd, but if you think "best efforts" could be described as hiring a subcontractor to deliver something for an entire continent from one plant, then I have a lovely bridge to sell you.

Sorry mate, but neither you nor I know how the biological product is produced, how scalable it is, how long it takes to get facilities off the ground, etc. etc. etc.

The burden of proof is on the EU to say how AZ haven't made "best efforts".

As said, with a product that didn't exist 12 months ago and wasn't available for sale anywhere in the world until 3-4 weeks ago... good luck to them with that.
 
Sorry mate, but neither you nor I know how the biological product is produced, how scalable it is, how long it takes to get facilities off the ground, etc. etc. etc.

The burden of proof is on the EU to say how AZ haven't made "best efforts".

As said, with a product that didn't exist 12 months ago and wasn't available for sale anywhere in the world until 3-4 weeks ago... good luck to them with that.

It is, but as I said if "best efforts" here means hiring a subby then really it doesn't mean anything at all.
 
pete, please read the rest of that exchange - its explained already

I posted this a few days back so Bruce could see the process...

 
Someone somewhere will be made the sacrificial goat for this.

Wonder how much internal political wrangling will be getting done to make sure that they are the one not left without a chair when the music stops

It's triggering an article in an international treaty; it's not something the office secretary can do on the sly like haha

Buck stops at the very top.
 
Someone somewhere will be made the sacrificial goat for this.

Wonder how much internal political wrangling will be getting done to make sure that they are the one not left without a chair when the music stops

Well the Germans won’t want it to be VDL, unless Merkel decides she wants it for herself. Obviously no one from France will be pointed at.....so I’m going with someone from ........Greece......
 
I posted this a few days back so Bruce could see the process...


yes, and please read that

if you can find the bit that says "and in the event of a global pandemic, its fine to get one continent to rely on one plant" then I'll give you some rep
 
Contract law isn't my forté, but if applying common sense then if the AZ supply chain has broken due to unforeseen circumstances, then that's two things - one, a breach of contract, as they aren't supplying the vaccine, but second I can't see how anyone could really say they haven't put best efforts in unless they prove they could have foreseen it and didn't fix it (good luck with proving that in regards to a medicine developed within a year) and/or when noted it was rectified quick enough - again, the timeframe doesn't suit a claimant there.

Occam's Razor again for me - EU ordered late, supply chain buckled, new product developed at warp speed needing to be scaled up massively to blame, 'it is what it is'.
Two issues I think - the best efforts in building capacity' and best efforts to deliver vaccines.

It will depend on the APA and what expectations were built into that regarding warning and notification of disruption as well.

I've not read it yet so couldn't say with any degree of certainty about any of it.
 
Why wouldn't it?

Again, talking about a product that didn't exist 12 months ago. If I'm a Judge I'm laughing any attempt out of court which tries to state AZ should have had fifty plants raring and ready to go with a product that wasn't even approved for sale anywhere until 3-4 weeks ago.
That is what the APA is for I think.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top