I agree with you about the welfare. I don't believe that people who genuinely come to work here do so with the intent of then taking advantage of our benefits system. They come to work and either stay or to send money back to their families. I have no problem with any of this providing it doesn't undermine UK workers rights.
I also agree that the recruiters are much better placed than anyone in government to decide upon skills required, again, provided that it does not undermine the UK worker or attempt to drive down employment rights.......
It does seem to me however that the UK worker is working against the odds. Many European peoples speak English as a second language, but very few UK workers are fluent in another European language and so it feels that there is no reciprocity in terms of worker movement.....
Oh for sure, but I wonder if that isn't always going to be the case to an extent. For the record, I'm not talking specifically about British workers here so much the lowly skilled. Globalisation has proved a real challenge for such folks, whether it's migrants coming in or jobs going out. Automation has already affected low-skilled work, and is likely to do so even more in the next decade or so, with jobs like driving and building automated (alongside many skilled jobs too it should be said).
Maybe the genie will be able to be put back into the bottle, but I'm inclined to think that there will always be someone or something that is going to provide you with a real challenge for your job, especially if you don't have much in the way of marketable skills to bring to bare.
I get fully that this is tough, especially for those raised on the job for life myth, and the education system isn't equipped yet to tailor for this constant re-skilling. Some advocate things like a universal income, both to buffer the impact and also provide some breathing space to do that re-training. I'm not sure that's the answer, but I'm equally not sure leaving the EU will be either.
I mean fruit pickers are a regular source of opprobrium, but even if we prevent farmers from hiring EU migrants to do that job, some Cambridge researchers have already built a robot that can do it just as well. As soon as such a thing becomes cost-effective, what then?
Similar devices are being developed in professions from driving to cooking, bricklaying to store work. What will these folks blame in 5/10 years time when their situation isn't any better?