2025/26 David Moyes

Readership has been in decline for years and I doubt many Blues give them much attention. It's why they're all in on the kopite road show, draws more clicks. Sadly, genuine local media has been dead almost everywhere for years. Certainly outside of London anyway.
It's all about relationship management to keep their seats in official club tours and granting access to exclusives like what Mark Travers thinks about the food selection in whichever armpit state of the US our preseason brings us to.
 
Yep, if being 12th and tamely out of both cups straight away is regarded as anything resembling ‘success’ for Everton football club, then that is quite pathetic.

We are just existing.
I mean, even Moyes loyalists would blanche at this being considered "success". To be fair to them, they'd argue it was some form of progress or improvement over recent seasons, but they wouldn't be so tin-eared as to describe it as success.

It appears competent mediocrity is the new success at Everton.
 
Just listening to a podcast, Everton focused, an they were talking about our lack of a striker and they were talking about how good Lukaku was for us and what we’d give for a 21 year Lukaku now. One of the contributors mentioned that in Lukaku’s last two seasons with Martinez we went at 1.2 points a games 91 from 75 games, year Moyes is on 60 from 40 games (1.5 per game) with Beto being the mainstay during that period.
Roberto's last two seasons were a study in underachievement. We were disastrous those seasons. His first year, when Moyes's defence was still in its prime, was magnificent as he provided a massive breath of fresh air and had us have a proper go for the first time in a generation. But that only gets you so far for so long when there's not much more than positivity to fall back on. The signing of McGeady was the beginning of the end...

Moyes's problem is he doesn't appear to know what a good striker actually is. He has signed so few of them over the years. Yakubu was the exception and injuries killed him. Lukaku would have gone nuts in a Moyes team.
 
Roberto's last two seasons were a study in underachievement. We were disastrous those seasons. His first year, when Moyes's defence was still in its prime, was magnificent as he provided a massive breath of fresh air and had us have a proper go for the first time in a generation. But that only gets you so far for so long when there's not much more than positivity to fall back on. The signing of McGeady was the beginning of the end...

Moyes's problem is he doesn't appear to know what a good striker actually is. He has signed so few of them over the years. Yakubu was the exception and injuries killed him. Lukaku would have gone nuts in a Moyes team.
Agree. But his first spell was under Kenwright and strikers have never been cheap, so good strikers were never really a conversation we belonged in. Yakubu was a fantastic signing, such a better player than I’d imagined him to be at the time.

I found the podcast interesting as points per game is always an interesting comparison. Not sure how many managers went at better than 1.5 points per game, Carlo Ancelotti went at 1.53 points per game during his spell. That was over 67 league games. So Moyes could easily equal that
 
Roberto's last two seasons were a study in underachievement. We were disastrous those seasons. His first year, when Moyes's defence was still in its prime, was magnificent as he provided a massive breath of fresh air and had us have a proper go for the first time in a generation. But that only gets you so far for so long when there's not much more than positivity to fall back on. The signing of McGeady was the beginning of the end...

Moyes's problem is he doesn't appear to know what a good striker actually is. He has signed so few of them over the years. Yakubu was the exception and injuries killed him. Lukaku would have gone nuts in a Moyes team.

In his last season here: two cup SFs and an 11th place PL finish.

If Moyes had done that this season there'd have been people on here carrying around giant Moyesatollah portraits and flagellating themselves.
 
In his last season here: two cup SFs and an 11th place PL finish.

If Moyes had done that this season there'd have been people on here carrying around giant Moyesatollah portraits and flagellating themselves.
True. But after his first season, the decline to 11th was steep. It's all relative. Lots depends on where you start from. Moyes is very fortunate indeed that so much of our fanbase is still suffering PTSD after the near-death experience Moshiri took us through building that stadium.
 
For all Moyes talk about going full throttle he doesn’t want to commit to pace at the back (JoB) so we can play higher and press higher - that alone would fix a lot of our issues, including the atmosphere at BMD. He is too safety first to ever go full throttle
Moyes idea of going full throttle is ordering a can of Irn Bru with his fish supper .
 
In his last season here: two cup SFs and an 11th place PL finish.

If Moyes had done that this season there'd have been people on here carrying around giant Moyesatollah portraits and flagellating themselves.

Martinez's time on paper looks great in comparison to others but the football in that final season was dreadful and we were in full free fall. It was when we got spanked by Sunderland and Leicester that I'd seen enough.
 

Similar Threads

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top