Transfer Rumour Tyler Dibling

[sanctioned]

To be fair to Bluewolf he has a point that Wirtz could bomb ala Nunez who they also spent huge on

New signings are always successful until they play

 

[Blueclouds]

Always a gamble with young players, this lad looks like he quality. Prices are silly these days so 40 million about right.

 

[Ragnar]

I don’t think it’s a gamble at all. Dibling has played in the PL, he know what it’s about, and he played in arguably the worth PL team ever and yet still had his admirers. If he comes to us and scores between 5-10 goals we would easily make money on him.

 

[sanctioned]

I don’t think it’s a gamble at all. Dibling has played in the PL, he know what it’s about, and he played in arguably the worth PL team ever and yet still had his admirers. If he comes to us and scores between 5-10 goals we would easily make money on him.

Think i agree with this. Issue is the price Southampton want limits our profit but if we get 3 great seasons out of him it might be worth it

 

[Ragnar]

Think i agree with this. Issue is the price Southampton want limits our profit but if we get 3 great seasons out of him it might be worth it

Exactly. If we buy him for 40, keep him 3 years and sell him for 60, we still make around 44m on the books for PSR. It doesn’t take much nowadays for a player to be worth 60m either.

 

[Eggs]

Exactly. If we buy him for 40, keep him 3 years and sell him for 60, we still make around 44m on the books for PSR. It doesn’t take much nowadays for a player to be worth 60m either.

….or he could be an expensive flop that we’re stuck with. The player has to be a success for his stock to rise but that’s the risk you take.

 

[Ragnar]

….or he could be an expensive flop that we’re stuck with. The player has to be a success for his stock to rise but that’s the risk you take.

And so could Fofana, Kubo, etc….. Any expensive players has its risks, but some fans turn a blind eye to that when there from abroad even tho they have never even seen them play. I just think Dibling knows what this league is all about, everybody who seen him last season could see he has talent, it just didn’t help he was in that Southampton team.

 

[dixiesdisciple]

Was Dibling part of the England u21 squad this summer? Has he ever been? I think Carsley is a good judge of a player and tends to back his own judgement rather than hype, so be interested to know

 

[bluestevon]

Was Dibling part of the England u21 squad this summer? Has he ever been? I think Carsley is a good judge of a player and tends to back his own judgement rather than hype, so be interested to know

No he has Elliot on the right with I think Hutchison as back up

 

[Eggsyblueskin]

And so could Fofana, Kubo, etc….. Any expensive players has its risks, but some fans turn a blind eye to that when there from abroad even tho they have never even seen them play. I just think Dibling knows what this league is all about, everybody who seen him last season could see he has talent, it just didn’t help he was in that Southampton team.

I do think Fofana is slightly further along his development, and maybe slightly less of a risk , fine margins though .
Kubo would have been the best option in terms of perceived risk .
Unfortunately for Dibling the price tag and the fact he has had PL experience means he will be under pressure to perform immediately. ( if we sign him of course)

 

[Jebus_lives]

A) but not in the PL and he's now playing in the PL

B) Abdul Baba Rahman, Marko Marin, Shinji Kagawa, Henrikh Mkhitaryan, Bastian Schweinsteiger, Jadon Sancho, Christian Pulisic, Timo Werner, keita, Jean-Kévin Augustin, seb haller, leon bailey, Lukas poldolski and owen Hargreaves to name a few

I'm not sure if you're being serious here.

You’re comparing those World Cup and multiple Champions League winners to some guy from the German league.

Yes, all unproven in the PL.

I know you're both probably hoping Wirtz is a flop at Liverpool, he may well be, but he's not unproven. They're paying big money precisely because he's 22 and has been a standout player in multiple seasons.

 

[Nymzee]

Was Dibling part of the England u21 squad this summer? Has he ever been? I think Carsley is a good judge of a player and tends to back his own judgement rather than hype, so be interested to know

No

 

[GoldenToffee]

Would strongly prefer a lower fee with higher add-ons if he reaches the potential Southampton think he has to be honest. £40m for somebody who doesn't even play for the u21s is crazy money.

If he turns out that good, I'm sure the club would be willing to forfeit a percentage of a next sale and pay more if he becomes and England regular, etc.

Anyway, as long as we get in the other players that were desperately need, I guess it means the money is there so I'll go with whatever the club decide.

 

[Nymzee]

Would strongly prefer a lower fee with higher add-ons if he reaches the potential Southampton think he has to be honest. £40m for somebody who doesn't even play for the u21s is crazy money.

If he turns out that good, I'm sure the club would be willing to forfeit a percentage of a next sale and pay more if he becomes and England regular, etc.

Anyway, as long as we get in the other players that were desperately need, I guess it means the money is there so I'll go with whatever the club decide.

He has played for the U21's, he just wasn't taken to the Euros because Carsley took the players who helped us qualify - as he should.

 

[Harryflashman]

To be fair to Bluewolf he has a point that Wirtz could bomb ala Nunez who they also spent huge on

Surely Any player whether you spend £100m or £100k can bomb ? The more you spend feels like you mitigate that risk but it’s not a guarantee