McCarthy is absolutely rubbish and would be very high on my list of players to sell if he could keep himself fit enough for anyone to have any interest in him. He has virtually no footballing ability at all, but occasionally comes into a lethargic team and everyone thinks he’s boss because he runs more than the others and maybe even makes some absolutely ridiculous slide tackles which get him booked and could get him sent off but PASSION yurrrrs.
Harsh to say he doesn't have footballing ability. He proved during RM's first two seasons that he does.
That hamstring injury that he was rushed back from in 14/15 set him back massively. I reckon Silva would like that kind of player in terms of how McCarthy can press and get about the pitch.
But this isn't absence making me grow fond of him again. It's easy to forget he exists because of the injuries and it's clear that at 27 he's never getting back to the player he was when we signed him, which tbf suited a very particular type of system where his main job on the ball was to turnover possession.
But as it stands it's about getting him fit again either way.