Current Affairs Stocks and shares and stuff

Status
Not open for further replies.
We may be about to find out as it seems that at least some of the sales weren’t margin calls

So apparently Citadel owns both Robin Hood and Melvin Capital (one of the hedge funds involved in the short squeeze).

hxekb8zf14e61.jpg
 
The amazing thing about it is this is the only time in history I can think of where the super rich have been outplayed at their own game of moving money by a bunch of Joe Publics doing nothing but simply buying shares.

The funny thing is all the rich who always call for "free markets" are now wanting restrictions and laws to protects themselves :lol:
 
Musk is on the money and that reply merits no attention.
Why not, it points out the hypocrisy and illogic of Musk’s comments about being able to sell things you don’t own?

I think there are many things you can be critical about in how shorting is abused in practice but the concept itself, of trading things you don’t own at that particular time, I don’t have much of a problem with.
 
Why not, it points out the hypocrisy and illogic of Musk’s comments about being able to sell things you don’t own?

I think there are many things you can be critical about in how shorting is abused in practice but the concept itself, of trading things you don’t own at that particular time, I don’t have much of a problem with.

As the replies to that dimwitted tweet point out, Musk owns the factories that produce the cars that will be sold.
 
So apparently Citadel owns both Robin Hood and Melvin Capital (one of the hedge funds involved in the short squeeze).

hxekb8zf14e61.jpg
I mentioned earlier in this thread about this. This guy is incorrect in most of what he says but the final point is correct. Citadel don't own Melvin but were one of the 2 hedge funds to bail them out this week (along with Point72). They also don't own Robinhood but are the biggest buyers of their order flow (which is basically the only way RH makes money).

The whole situation stinks and I just hope the latecomers who don't understand the situation aren't going to get completely screwed. Sadly a lot of them will be
 
As the replies to that dimwitted tweet point out, Musk owns the factories that produce the cars that will be sold.
He might have owned the means of manufacture (although iirc some of the time he used the pre-orders to get financing to even build the factories/alter existing production or buy materials so even that is a tad questionabl) but he still didn’t own the cars that he sold pre-orders on ie he still traded an asset he did not own at that time.

Expanding it out further if ever you have sold a stock within a couple of days you have also technically traded an asset you don’t own as settlement date is different from purchase date as you are assuming that everyone in the chain fulfills their promises/obligations.

As I say none of this is a defense of short selling, just that I don’t think the “you can’t trade it as you don’t own it” holds much water.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top