orly
Please check with me for Blammo criteria
Exactly mate. And won't even be close to the amount of money and wages spent on Mina so far, an investment which looks as fragile as his broken feet.
- Status
Exactly mate. And won't even be close to the amount of money and wages spent on Mina so far, an investment which looks as fragile as his broken feet.
B
Big Fat Sam
Guest
I give Walsh 3/10 for his work with us, and that's generous imo.
Lukaku now would likely sell for a similar fee (80-90m), imo. Maybe we'll see this summer. But United definitely passed Rooney off as being worth about 20m in that transfer.
Plus we got the honour of being able to pay him 150k to play for us.Take away Rooney's penalties and he was an unmitigated disaster for us. Good hat trick against West Ham, though! No ill will towards him from me, but he should never have been allowed anywhere near Everton at that stage of his career, on that money.
I can agree that Walsh did some good things, but the big-money signings he made as still causing us to suffer, and that says it all. Lost huge money in offloading certain players, and can't find takers for many others while they bleed us dry.
Simon Buttle
Player Valuation: £50m
I still can't get my head around the fact that prior to us signing Tosun he had just been top scorer in the Champions League group stage, yet playing for us it looked like he had his ankles zip tied together.
ArtetaMagic
Player Valuation: £15m
It's not the £5 million that's the problem it's the £100k a week contract for 4/5 years
davids
Player Valuation: £60m
Might be because the CL isn't all it's hyped up to be,some of the group games work better than Valium.
davids
Player Valuation: £60m
Moshiri and others might have been aware of that,Walsh just makes an easier target.
orly
Please check with me for Blammo criteria
I give Walsh 3/10 for his work with us, and that's generous imo.
Lukaku now would likely sell for a similar fee (80-90m), imo. Maybe we'll see this summer. But United definitely passed Rooney off as being worth about 20m in that transfer.
Take away Rooney's penalties and he was an unmitigated disaster for us. Good hat trick against West Ham, though! No ill will towards him from me, but he should never have been allowed anywhere near Everton at that stage of his career, on that money.
I can agree that Walsh did some good things, but the big-money signings he made as still causing us to suffer, and that says it all. Lost huge money in offloading certain players, and can't find takers for many others while they bleed us dry.
Nah, Siggurdson and Keane, for example, were far worse that season, and now for better coaching are much improved. Rooney would have no doubt flourished too. Top scorer and best player in a team embroiled in problems is a pretty good return.
It's interesting too that Brands has hardly overhauled the youth setup, an U-21 side that won the league in the Walsh era and continues to benefit from his structures again this season.
And the fact we’re struggling to give him away as he’s gone about 40 games without scoring across two loan spells.
orly
Please check with me for Blammo criteria
Or perhaps he limited the true level of damage that Allardyce and Koeman could have wrought. Working behind the scenes to little credit.
B
Big Fat Sam
Guest
Another minimum 18m on top of that in guaranteed wages over 5 years, n'all.
I give Walsh 3/10 for his work with us, and that's generous imo.
Lukaku now would likely sell for a similar fee (80-90m), imo. Maybe we'll see this summer. But United definitely passed Rooney off as being worth about 20m in that transfer.
Take away Rooney's penalties and he was an unmitigated disaster for us. Good hat trick against West Ham, though! No ill will towards him from me, but he should never have been allowed anywhere near Everton at that stage of his career, on that money.
I can agree that Walsh did some good things, but the big-money signings he made as still causing us to suffer, and that says it all. Lost huge money in offloading certain players, and can't find takers for many others while they bleed us dry.
The thing with Rooney was his wages. For the top earner at the club by a distance, you’d expect someone that would be half-considered for the top 3 in your Player of the Season discussion at the end of the season. As it turned out, that was not the case.
davids
Player Valuation: £60m
That was the biggy,we all knew that other than the odd fluke against our Heysel denying neighbours that he was and continues to be naff.But again,others were involved and have eyes.
- Status
