Things have gotten worse after Koeman left, although that's not any defense of Koeman.
We went from a goal drought to finding the net on a much more consistent basis, although our defensive woes have been chronic this season.
Main criticisms on the team sheet:
1. Calvert Lewin cannot play alone up top. His game against City was a miracle, but he's a kid. He needs a strike partner. Lukaku needed a partner too... Valencia is a sore miss for the team this year his work rate and creativity helped.
2. Where. Is. Holgate? He's an athlete, he's strong, and he's fairly quick. Our experienced players at the back are acting like children... Keane began his career well, but he's also young and struggling without leadership around him. If the old guard CAN'T do the trick, WHERE IS HOLGATE?
3. Schneiderlin. What does he offer? Gana's numbers have actually increased recently, especially when he plays with Schneiderlin. He doesn't press well, his passing range is stale, he isn't putting in strong challenges and he is a literal waste of a player tactically right now. Davis is free at the edge of the box... while we have 2 CDMs on the pitch. HOW? Gana hasn't been stellar, but his running stats speak for themselves. Even Sigs is getting up and down the pitch, and that's not his proper role.
4. The wing-wide back combinations. Against Zaha, Kenny had an amazing game, but Lennon backed him up. Most of our problems came from Baines being caught out, and both goals against Palace came from down the right. In this game there were two crosses to Austin from the left, but only after Kenny moved across field. The fourth goal came from Lookman not tracking a man's run while Kenny closed the ball down. Ball centered to edge of box and Davis is free to score. Lennon-Kenny I think is an alright partnership, but we need SOMETHING for that left hand side of the field.
5. We can't play 3 number 10s, but we need at least ONE. Sigurdsson looked like a box-to-box midfielder today... if that's his new position, fine, but DCL can't perform without assistance. Runs up the field to support him in the pocket are near non existent, Rooney would be a nice impact sub, but we're missing... well, Barkley. Yes, Barkley can be an insufferable whiny bitch at times, but he's a big strong footballer, and he has a great eye for the game. We miss him.
We look like a physically weak side with no decent touch. Our dismal 30% possession stats for a few games confirm that. We need players who can pressure and win the ball back, but also who can play confidently in possession.
Hopefully in a few weeks we can get the following line up out there:
Bolasie-Niasse-Lennon
Davies-Sigurdsson
Gueye
Kenny-Keane-Holgate-Coleman
Pickford
Bolasie and Lennon are both hard workers out wide and will help our wide backs, each of whom both like to give us width. Niasse is in the goals, and the midfield is hardworking but the best I can see being put out right now. Keane and Holgate together are a risk, and is subject to change... but god we need a CB partnership that works.
Rooney, Lookman, Vlasic, DCL, Jagielka, Klaassen, Joel on the bench.
Fairly attacking bench too, but it's a much more adaptable bench as well. Late on in games we're usually struggling, which means offensive tweaks more than defensive tweaks. Lookman for fresh legs and pace, DCL for aerial threat, Klaassen for pressure, Vlasic for a creative outlet, Rooney for a distribution outlet. Joel for penalty double saves (I still love Joel, but he's not m number one)