Everton are the worst team in the Premier League at winning aerial duels in their own third of the field, winning only 48.2 percent, and second worse in their own penalty area at 45 percent. Teams have completed 77 crosses against them, the fifth most in the league, at 23.8 percent, also the fifth highest. Those crosses have resulted in 49 shots, that's the most shots conceded from crosses in the league, and those shots have ended up in the back of the net 8 times, the second most of any time.
The problem has been particularly acute on set plays. Half of the goals from crosses they've conceded have been from set plays, either corners or free kicks. Opponents are completing their pass 40.5 percent of the time in those situations, the worst performance by a defense in the league. The result is that again, the shooting numbers don't make Howard look bad, because since Everton are poor at defending the original pass, Howard has faced 40 shots assisted by a pass from these dead ball situations, the worst in the league.